Author:
Jody A.Vogel
Suzanne Z.Barkin
Description
- Child abuse impacts up to 14 million or 2-3% of U.S. children each year
- 1,200-1,400 children die of maltreatment each year in the U.S. Of these, 80% <5 yr and 40% <1 yr
- Mand ated reporters of suspected abuse or neglect include all health care workers
- Risk factors:
- Child: Usually <4 yr, often disabled or special needs (vulnerable child), premature birth, or multiple birth
- Abusive parent: Low self-esteem, abused as child, violent temper, mental illness history, rigid and unrealistic expectations of child, or young maternal age
- Family: Monetary problems, isolated and mobile, or marital instability
- Poor parent-child relationship, unwanted pregnancy
- Abuse affects all races, ethnicities religious, and socioeconomic groups
Signs and Symptoms
History
- Begin with open-ended questions about injury and mechanism
- No all-inclusive list of signs of abuse
- Seek environmental information from prehospital personnel
- Patterns of presentation that should raise concern for abuse or neglect:
- History and mechanism inconsistent with injury or illness
- Unexplained death, apnea, and injury
- Unexplained ingestion or toxin exposure:
- Recurrent injury
- Parent/caregiver reluctant to give information or denies knowledge of how injury occurred
- Discrepant or inconsistent histories among different caregivers
- History of injury incident changes over time
- Injury does not correlate with child's developmental abilities
- Inappropriate response of care provider to injury or illness; delay in seeking care
- Munchausen by proxy:
- Recurrent illness without medical explanation
- Unexplained metabolic disorder suspicious for poisoning
- Failure to thrive:
- Inadequate caloric intake secondary to poor parental bonding/neglect
- Review of past ED encounters and primary care visits may be helpful to identify trends in development and weight gain
Physical Exam
- Injury not consistent with history
- Injuries from nonaccidental trauma are generally of greater severity than from accidental trauma
- Cutaneous bruising/contusions:
- Before child is mobile. Bruising is uncommon before 5 mo without trauma
- Regular pattern, straight line of demarcation, regular angles, slap marks from fingers, dunking burns (stocking or glove burns or doughnut shaped), bites, strap, buckle, cigarette burns
- Location: Buttocks, hips, face (not forehead), arms, back, thighs, genitalia, or pinna
- Aging of bruises:
- Often different ages of bruises
- Yellow bruises are older than 18 hr
- Red, blue and purple, or black color may occur from 1 hr after injury to resolution
- Red may be present irrespective of age
- Bruises of identical age and cause on the same person may appear to be different
- Skeletal trauma:
- Usually multiple, unexplained, various stages of healing
- Metaphyseal or corner (classic metaphyseal lesions) fractures (pathognomonic)
- Skull fractures that cross suture lines
- Posterior rib fractures (rib fractures almost never occur in infants from CPR)
- Spiral fractures of long bones
- Subperiosteal new bone formation
- Uncommon fractures (vertebrae, sternum, scapula, spinous process) without significant mechanism
- CNS:
- Altered mental status or seizure
- Head trauma is leading cause of death in child abuse
- Skull fracture: Must consider child abuse in children <1 yr
- Subdural hematoma, subarachnoid hemorrhage
- Shaken baby syndrome with shearing and rotational injury
- Ocular findings:
- Retinal hemorrhage or detachment:
- 65-90% of abusive head injury has retinal hemorrhage (commonly bilateral) while present in only 0-10% severe accidental trauma
- Rare in the absence of evidence of head trauma and normal neuroimaging
- Hyphema
- Corneal abrasion/conjunctival hemorrhage
- Ophthalmologic exam recommended for children under 3 yr in setting of suspected abuse
- Oral trauma
- Abdominal injuries:
- Lacerated liver, spleen, kidney, or pancreas
- Intramural hematoma (duodenal most common)
- Retroperitoneal hematoma
- Anogenital/sexual abuse:
- May have normal genitourinary exam
- May have contusion, erythema, open wounds, scarring, or foreign material (hair, debris, or semen)
- Presence of STD or pregnancy in child <12 yr
- Death:
Essential Workup
- Formal report to appropriate child welfare agency
- Family and environmental evaluation, in cooperation with responsible child welfare agency
- Thorough documentation of examination findings
- Diagram or photograph of bruises is especially helpful
ALERT |
When suspected, health professionals have a legal obligation to report their suspicion to the appropriate authorities |
Diagnostic Tests & Interpretation
Lab
- Bleeding screen if there is a history of recurrent bruising or bruising is the prominent manifestation; may usually be done electively: CBC, platelets, PT/PTT, or bleeding time (or PFA collagen epinephrine)
- If significant blunt trauma, CBC, LFT, amylase, lipase, and urinalysis for hematuria
- Toxicology, chemistry, and metabolic screens in children with altered mental status
- Consider other differential considerations
Imaging
- Guidelines for obtaining skeletal survey in children without verifiable accidental trauma, inconsistent history, underlying bone fragility, or a significant history of birth trauma:
- 0-23 mo olds with any of the following with associated fracture(s):
- History of confessed abuse
- History of injury during domestic violence
- History of impact from toy or other object causing fracture
- Delay in seeking care >24 hr
- No history of trauma to explain fracture except for following in child >12 mo: Distal buckle fracture of radius/ulna or distal spiral or buckle fracture of tibia/fibula with consistent mechanism
- 0-11 mo olds with any type of fracture except in the following cases if no additional concerns:
- Distal radial/ulna fracture or toddler fracture of tibia/fibula in cruising child ≥9 mo with trauma history
- Linear, unilateral skull fracture in child >6 mo with history of significant accidental fall
- Clavicle fracture attributable to birth
- 12-23 mo olds with any of following fractures:
- Rib fracture
- Classic metaphyseal fracture
- Complex or ping pong skull fracture
- Humeral fracture with epiphyseal separation from short (<3 ft) fall
- Femur diaphyseal fracture from a fall
- Skeletal survey may be appropriate as clinically indicated
- Global assessment:
- Indicated for children <2 yr to exclude unsuspected injuries when abuse suspected
- In children 2-5 yr, in selected cases where physical abuse is strongly suspected
- In older children, radiographs of individual sites of injury suspected on clinical grounds
- Radiographic skeletal survey:
- Anteroposterior (AP) and lateral skull
- Lateral cervical spine
- AP and lateral thoracic and lumbar spine
- AP and obliques of chest
- AP pelvis
- AP humerus, forearm, and hand s (bilateral)
- AP femur, tibia, and feet (bilateral)
- If fracture identified, get at least 2 views, 90 degrees to original view
- May need coned-down view of joints for visualization of classic metaphyseal lesions
- Skeletal scintigraphy provides adjunctive screening if suspicion exists beyond skeletal survey
- Visceral imaging:
- Suspected thoracoabdominal injury:
- Abdominal CT scan with IV and possibly oral contrast
- Neuroimaging:
- Nonenhanced head CT with brain, subdural, and bone windowing
- MRI:
- Adjunctive in evaluation of acute, subacute, and chronic intracranial injury; useful for shear injuries, evolving hemorrhage, contusion, or secondary hypoxic/ischemic injury
Differential Diagnosis
- General:
- Trauma - accidental or birth/obstetrical
- Cutaneous:
- Burn - accidental
- Infection
- Impetigo/cellulitis
- Staphylococcal scalded skin syndrome
- Henoch-Schönlein purpura
- Purpura fulminans/meningococcemia
- Sepsis
- Dermatitis: Contact or photo
- Hematologic/oncologic disorder (idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura [ITP], leukemia)
- Bleeding diathesis (hemophilia, von Willebrand )
- Nutritional deficiency: Scurvy
- Cultural healing practices (coining, cupping)
- Skeletal:
- Osteogenesis imperfecta
- Nutritional (rickets, copper deficiency, or scurvy)
- Menkes syndrome
- Peripheral sensory impairment (indifference to pain)
- Ocular:
- Abdomen and GU tract:
- GI disease (obstruction, peritonitis, or inflammatory bowel disease)
- GU tract infection/anomaly
- CNS:
- Intoxication, ingestion (CO, lead, or mercury)
- Infection:
- Metabolic: Hypoglycemia
- Epilepsy
- Death:
- SIDS, apparent life-threatening event (ALTE)
Prehospital
- Diagnosis relies on physical evidence in child and inconsistency with the history and mechanism
- Examination of the scene may be useful:
- Evaluate validity of mechanisms
- General appearance of home
- Consistency of history by multiple caregivers
- Evaluation of parent-child interaction
Initial Stabilization/Therapy
As indicated by specific injury
ED Treatment/Procedures
- Medical and trauma management as required
- If child abuse team or specialist available at facility, consult them early in evaluation
- Mand atory reporting to local child welfare agency of any suspected child abuse to determine appropriate social disposition:
- This does not imply or require 100% certainty of abuse
- Expedited family, environmental, and social evaluation
- Essential to be nonjudgmental
- Communication with family about report and primary concern is responsibility of child welfare:
- Security may be required to protect child and staff
- Siblings and other household children must be examined in appropriate time frame
- EscobarMA Jr, Flynn-O'BrienK, AuerbachM, et al. The association of nonaccidental trauma with historical factors, examination findings, and diagnostic testing during the initial trauma evaluation . J Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2017;82:1147-1157.
- EstroffJM, FogliaRP, FuchsJR. A comparison of accidental and nonaccidental trauma: It is worse than you think . J Emerg Med. 2015;48:274-279.
- Fisher-OwensSA, LukefahrJL, TateAR. Oral and dental aspects of child abuse and neglect . Pediatrics. 2017;140(2):e20171487.
- KleinmanPK, ed. Diagnostic Imaging of Child Abuse. 3rd ed.Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 2015.
- MacleanMJ, SimsS, BowerC, et al. Maltreatment risk among children with disabilities . Pediatrics. 2017;139(4):e20161817.
- MulderTM, KuiperKC, van der PutGJM, et al. Risk factors for child neglect: A meta-analytic review . Child Abuse Negl. 2018;77:198-210.
- PawlikMC, KempA, MaguireS, et al. Children with burns referred for child abuse evaluation: Burn characteristics and co-existent injuries . Child Abuse Negl. 2016;55:52-61.
- PierceMC, MaganaJN, KaczorK, et al. The prevalence of bruising among infants in pediatric emergency departments . Ann Emerg Med. 2016;67:1-8.
- ShaahinfarA, WhitelawKD, MansourKM. Update on abusive head trauma . Curr Opin Pediatr. 2015;27:308-314.
- SlovisTL, StrousePJ, StraussKJ. Radiation exposure in imaging of suspected child abuse: Benefits versus risks . J Pediatr. 2015;167(5):963-968.
- WoodJN, FakeyeO, FeudtnerC, et al. Development of guidelines for skeletal survey in young children with fractures . Pediatrics. 2014;134:45-62.
See Also (Topic, Algorithm, Electronic Media Element)