A. Definitions and Characteristics
- Infertility diagnosis usually made when conception has not occurred within 1 year of unprotected sexual exposure in a couple
- Sterility usually requires infertility and no effective therapy
- Overall, humans have a monthly (ovulatory) fecundity rate ~20%
- Chances of pregnancy with average fertility 74% at 6 months, 93% 1 year, 100% 2 years
- Chances of pregnancy with 1-5% monthly fecundity 5-25% at 6 months, 20-70% 2 years
- Rates of Infertility
- Of married couples who desire children, 10-15% in USA are childless
- About 33% of women who defer pregnancy until mid- to late 30s are unable to conceive
- About 50% of women who defer pregnancy until after age 40 are unable to conceive
- Estimated >6 million couples in USA with infertility
- Etiology of Infertility
- Ovulation disorders 17%
- Tubal disease 23%
- Endometriosis 6%
- Male factor 25%
- Combined factors 5%
- Idiopathic 25%
- Distinct from spontaneous pregnancy loss
B. Prevention of Infertility [3]
- Lifestyle Changes
- Stop smoking
- Stop recreational drug abuse
- Women reduce vigorous exercise, especially with history of abnormal menses
- Men avoid hot tubs, tight briefs, and stop use of anabolic steroids
- Reduce risk of sexually transmitted diseases (STD)
- Strongly recommend use of condoms
- Limit number of sexual partners
- Early screening and detection of STD in patients at risk
- All women with abnormal Papanicolaou Smears
- Patients with HIV infection
- Patients with previous STD
- History of preterm labor or ectopic pregnancy
- Chlamydia trachomatis infection increases risk for tubal infertility [4]
- Aggressive evaluation of pelvic pain and progressive dysmenorrhea
- Remind women that fertily reates decrease after 35 years of age
- Intrauterine devices do NOT increase risk for tubal infertility [4]
- Increasing options for preserving fertility in women [34]
C. Evaluation of Infertility
- Evaluation will yield results which lead to effective therapy in <50% of cases
- Consider duration of attempted pregnancy and likelihood of conception (see above)
- Complete medical history and physical examination
- Inquiry into frequency and timing of intercourse
- Use of lubricants (may be spermicidal or static) during intercourse
- Chronic anovulatory syndrome (PCOS)
- Endometriosis - also causes infertility
- Routine laboratory testing
- Complete blood count (CBC)
- Urinalysis
- Serologic testing for syphilis (RPR, VDRL, others)
- Glucose level and HbA1c (rule out diabetes and hyperglycemia)
- Recommendations on Intercourse
- No evidence that reducing intercourse frequency to "store up" sperm improves conception
- Intercourse advised for 2-3 days after rise in basal body temperature (mid cycle)
- Home urinary luteinizing hormone (LH) testing kits can be used to time LH surge
- Intercourse is then advised for 2-4 days beginning with LH surge
- Oligospermia is the only indication for relative abstinance
- Avoid lubricants; warm water may be used instead where required
- Investigation of Infertility
- After discussion of intercourse methods, several tests are used to evaluate infertility
- Semen analysis and examination of male genitalia and hormonal status
- Documentation of ovulation
- Post-coital test - for cervical mucus factors, generally not recommended (see below)
- Investigation of female upper genital tract (hysterosalpingography)
- Additional Tests
- These tests are performed if above tests are normal
- Thyroid secreting hormone (TSH) level to evaluate for hypothyroidism (common)
- Immunological tests
- Bacterial cultures of cervical mucus and semen
- Endometrial biopsy (to rule out inadequate luteal phase) - done last (invasive)
D. Evaluation of Male Fuction [2]
- History
- Familial syndromes - genetic defects, cystic fibrosis gene abnormalities, others
- Abdominal / pelvic surgery possibly suggesting cryptorchidism
- Physical Examination
- Abnormalities of genitourinary (GU) tract - hypospadias, varicoceles (see below)
- Penile plaques
- Testicular Exam - position, size, consistency (testicular cancer evaluation)
- Semen analysis
- First laboratory evaluation in the investigation of the infertile couple
- Sperm assessment is most critical part of evaluation
- Semen anti-sperm antibodies should be evaluated in any sperm function
- Sperm Assessment [6]
- Counts, motility, and morphology are critically evaluated
- Finding of leukocytes in ejaculate should prompt culture (treat documented infections)
- Sperm counts <1 million/mL constitute severe oligospermia
- Sperm counts <13.5 million/mL associated with subfertile ranges
- Sperm counts >48.0 million/mL associated with normal fertility
- Motility <32% and <9% normal morphology associated with subfertile range
- Oligospermia, azoospermia associated with increased rates of mutant androgen receptors
- Azoospermia
- Measure basal FSH (LH) and testosterone levels
- Elevated FSH - primary germinal epithelium failure
- Normal FSH - suggests obstruction (such as vas deferens obstruction)
- Presence of >20 CAG trinucleotide repeats in androgen receptor gene is associated with >6X increased risk of infertility due to abnormal sperm
- Hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (GnRH deficiency) is usually congenital and treatable [20]
- Testis biopsy is not usually performed and is of questionable benefit
- Varicocele repair does not appear to improve mail infertility [9]
E. Documentation of Ovulation [1]
- Any one or more of the following is done in an infertility evalatuion to document ovulation
- Serum Progesterone
- Perform on days 20-24 of menstrual cycle
- >3-5ng/mL is positive result
- Nearly all pregnancies have serum progesterone levels >10ng/mL
- May treat patients with <10ng/mL with clomiphene citrate
- Urinary LH surge Test
- Simple home test which can document surge, around day 20 of cycle
- ELISA based dipstick kit is used
- FSH on Day 3 in Woman [2]
- Indicated in woman >34 years old or with prior ovarian surgery
- Elevated basal FSH levels (>12-20 IU/L) associated with poor ovarian response to exogenous gonadotropins
- Basal Body Temperature (BBT)
- Progesterone causes increases in BBT
- This method is very inexpensive, sensitive, and requires little technology
- Generally no longer recommended as part of routine evaluation
- Normal biphasic shift has 0.4°F increase in body temperature (taken in AM on awakening)
- Luteal phase length should be greater than 11 days
- Ovulation actually occurs between lowest and highest points in BBT
- Endometrial Biopsy
- Performed between days 20 and 22 of cycle to demonstrate secretory endometrium
- May also be done to document "inadequate" luteal phase
- No longer recommended as part of routine evaluation
- Ultrasound - may be used to evaluate follicular development
[
Figure] "Hormonal Changes During the Menstrual Cycle"
F. Other Causes of Female Infertility [1]
- Chronic Anovulatory Syndrome [14]
- Also called polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS)
- Most cases associated with cysts in ovaries
- Comprises obesity (~60%), hirsutism, amenorrhea
- Insulin resistance and hypertension are very common
- Insulin resistance, diabetes, and hypertension all associated with reduced fertility
- Elevated levels of LH usually found
- Treatment with insulin sensitizing agents (metformin, glitazones) improves menses
- Anatomic Abnormalities
- Cervical incompetence
- Congenital uterine anomalies
- Adhesions and Leimyomas most common acquired uterine anomalies
- Hypothalamic Amenorrhea [33]
- Amenorrhea occurs in association with exercise in absence of organic disease
- Arises with impaired secretion of gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH)
- Leads to low or normal gonadotropin (FSH, LH), low estrogen, absent menstrual cycles
- Essentially a regression to prepubertal or peripubertal pattern of gonadotropin secretion
- Relative energy deficit plays major role in abnormal GnRH secretion
- Reduced leptin concentrations appear to be central in this syndrome
- Pharmacologic replacement of leptin may lead to normalization of endocrine axes, menses
- Other Endocrine Disorders
- Abnormal Thyroid Function
- Diabetes Mellitus
- Adrenal insufficiency (Addison's Disease)
- Polyglandular autoimmune syndrome type 1 (polyendocrine failure syndrome 1)
- Chemotherapeutic Agents
- Particularly intravenous alkylating agents (such as cyclophosphamide)
- Oral contraceptive pill use during chemotherapy treatment may prevent ovarian failure
- High dose chemotherapy (often with blood cell transplantation)
- Harvesting of eggs is more difficult and is time consuming
- Cryopreserved ovarian cortical strips have been used to restore ovulation after high dose chemotherapy for Hodgkin's Disease [12]
- Relatively Common Genetic Causes
- Parental genetic abnormalities: ~2.5%
- Turner's Syndromes
- Mosaicism
- Congenital pituitary insufficiency
- Single Gene (Uncommon) Genetic Abnormalities [11]
- Kallmann's Syndrome (1:50,000)
- GnRH Resistance
- FSH Deficiency
- LH Resistance (LH receptor abnormalities)
- Congenital lipoid adrenal hyperplasia
- Galactosemia (1:187,000)
- Hypergonadotropic hypogonadal ovarian failure [20]
- McCune-Albright Syndrome
- Aromatase Deficiency (CYP19 mutations)
- 17a-hydroxylase Deficiency
- Premature Ovarian Failure
- Accounts for ~15% of primary and ~10% of secondary amenorrhea
- Associated with elevated gonadotropin levels and infertily in women <40 years
- Various causes indlucing autoimmune, genetic, and chemotherapy induced
- Infections (Fetal Wastage)
- Autoimmune Disease
G. Other Causes of Male Infertility [2]
- Complete Germinal Failure
- Radiation Therapy - pelvic > abdominal radiation
- Chemotherapy - alkylators, combination therapy
- Testosterone may prevent cyclophosphamide induced azoospermia
- Orchitis (inflammatory) - mumps, tuberculosis, other
- Sertoli Cell Only Syndrome - azoospermia, no sperm lineage cells on biopsy (10-15%)
- Maturation Arrest - arrest of spermatogenesis
- Cryptorchidism - failed testicular decent, usually congenital
- In most of these disorders, FSH levels are >> LH levels
- Partial Germinal Failure
- Medications - chemotherapy, sulfa drugs, abused drugs (including alcohol)
- Endocrine Disorders - hypothyroidism, hyperprolactinemia, hypopituitarism
- Systemic Illness - usually severe forms, lead to oligospermia
- Idiopathic Oligospermia - most common cause of oligospermia
- Anatomic Abnormalities
- Varicocoele
- Obstruction of the Vas
- Disorders of Sperm Function
- Pure motility disturbances - poorly understood (likely structural protein defects)
- Abnormal Sperm maturation - sperm autoantibodies
- Inability of sperm to move through cervical mucus
- Non-penetration of sperm into Ova
- Up to 15% may be related to Y chromosome abnormalities
- An increasing but small proportion of men (7%) will have Y chromosome deletions
- Defective zona pellucida induced acrosome reaction (DZPIAR)
- DZPIAR [16]
- ~10% of in vitro fertilization (IVF) failures may be due to DZPIAR
- DZPIAR likely to achieve good success with intracytoplasmic sperm injection (see below)
- Both zona pellucida and progesterone can induce acrosome reaction
- Failure of progesterone induced acrosome reaction predicts failure of IVF
- Mutations in meiosis regulating protein SYCP3 (very rare) [29]
H. Infertility Treatment Overview [3,7]
- Treating any underlying factors is critical to success
- Radiographic methods, endoscopy or sugery for women with tubal obstruction
- Prior to chemo- or radiotherapy, cryopreservation of male semen is relatively simple
- Bromocriptine (D1/D2 agonist) recommended for hyperprolactinemia in desired pregnancy [30]
- Medical or surgical ablation of endometriosis
- Hormonal support of inadequate luteal phase (clomiphene or progesterone)
- In couples with infertily after 6-12 months, continued attempts without intervention were superior to ovarian hyperstimulation with intrauterine insemination after 6 months [10]
- In these "sub-fertile" couples regardless of treatment, ~33% conceived, ~25% carried [10]
- Overview of Assisted Reproduction [7]
- Ovulation hyperstimulation (superovulation)
- Intrauterine insemination
- Artificial insemination with sperm for male factor infertility
- In vitro fertilization (IVF)
- Most of these methods carry high risk of multiple births
- Ovarian Hyperstimulation
- Clomiphene citrate is typically first line in anovulatory women (see below)
- Follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) ± LH is often very effective [17,18]
- FSH induction (Bravelle®, others) must be followed by hCG
- Most effective in women with some ovulatory function and unobstructed genital tract
- Gonadotropin induction is associated with high risk of mutliple pregnancy [18]
- Increasing age, estrogen levels, and number of follicles correlated with multiple pregnancy
- Reducing dose of gonadotropins reduces multiple pregnancy, but also success rates [18]
- Intrauterine Insemination
- Motile sperm suspended in culture medium
- Then injected transcervically into uterine cavity
- Sperm must be motile
- Intrauterine insemination more effective than intracervical insemination [19]
- For idiopathic and male subfertility, intrauterine insemination is as effective as in vitro fertilization [19]
- Intrauterine insemination is effective and commonly performed
- "Post-coital" test for is no longer recommended [2]
- Combination Superovulation and Insemination [17]
- For unexplained infertility and male factor infertily
- Unobstructed female genital tract and motile sperm are required
- Overall success was 33% pregnancy
- IVF
- Unexplained infertily
- Normal or reduced sperm motility
- Reduced sperm counts (azoospermia)
- Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection
- Unexplained infertility
- Nonmotile or reduced motility sperm
- Other Sperm Abnormalities
- Preservation of Fertily in Cancer Patients [34]
- Ooporectomy and cryopreservation
- Ovariopexy during pelvic irradiation
- Aspiration of immature oocytes without stimulation (followed by in vitro techniques)
- Delay in aspiration (4-6 weeks) of oocytes with stimulation
- Tissue removal and cryopreservation, then thawing and in vitro or in vivo techniques
I. Treatment of Anovulation
- 10-15% of all infertile women are anovulatory
- Divided into primary amenorrhea, secondary amenorrhea, and oligomenorrhea
- Primary Amenorrhea
- Many patients have normal secondary sex characteristics
- Failed process of ovulation only
- These patients should recieve im injection of 100-200mg progesterone
- Normally this progesterone injection will cause withdrawal bleeding
- If estrogen pathway not functional, then endometrium not developed, thus no bleeding
- Patients with secondary amenorrhea should have similar progesterone injection
- After progesterone challenge, ~60% of patients will have uterine bleeding
- Patients with uterine bleeding should be treated with clomiphene citrate (Clomid®)
- Clomiphene Citrate (Clomid®)
- Clomiphene is an estrogen receptor modulator that induces ovulation
- Overall, ~80% of women will ovulate on clomiphene
- Of these, ~75% have term pregnancies, ~25% abort from drug
- Complications: ~5% multiple pregnancies, ~8% ovarian cysts, ~3% fetal abnormalities
- Careful monitoring can reduce risk of multiple pregnancies
- Side effects: vasomotor flushing (10%), abdominal complaints (6%), breast discomfort (2%)
- Clomiphene is started on 5th day of the cycle for five days
- Other Ovulation Inducing Agents
- Human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) can be given 7 days after clomiphene maximum
- Perganol (gonadotropins) induces ovulation in ~100% of patients
- Risks of other perganol are similar to those of clomiphene (% may be slightly higher)
- Cyst formation, ovarian hyperstimulation, may be reach ~10% (see below)
- Gonadtropin releasing hormone (GnRH) can be used iv or sc as well
- Ovulation inducing therapy should be tried for 3 cycles prior to further evaluation
- Superovulation is combined with uterine insemination as described above
- No increase in risk for ovarian cancer [3]
- Ovarian Hyperstimulation Syndrome (see below)
J. Ovarian Hyperstimulation Syndrome (OHS) [3]
- Most serious medical complation of iatrogenic superovulation
- Genetic form of OHS [27,28]
- Mutations in follicle-stimulating hormone receptor (FSH-R) found
- Leads to hypersensitivity to chorionic gonadotropin (HCG)
- Normally, FSH-R does not respond to HCG
- Mutant FSH-R responds to HCG with similar efficiency as FSH
- Pathophysiology
- Believed that abnormally elevated renin production by ovary initiates syndrome
- Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) production by ovary increases vascular permeability
- Cystic enlargement of ovaries and marked increase in vascular permeability
- Leads to extravasation of fluid, pelvic ascites (third spacing)
- This causes hemoconcentration, hypovolemia and hypercoagulation
- In addition to ascites, pleural and pericardial effusions may occur
- In severe hypovolemia, hepatic and renal dysfunction and hepatorenal syndrome can occur
- Symptoms
- Present with abdominal distention, nausea, vomiting, dyspnea
- Venous and arterial thromboses can occur
- Treatment
- Supportive care with maintenance of intravascular volume critical
- Paracentesis to relieve abdominal pain and pulmonary compromise
- Short term prophylaxis against thromboembolism (low molecular weight heparin) advised
- Termination of pregnancy may be required in very severe cases
K. In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) [5,7,8]
- IVF includes a variety of methods of "Assisted Reproductive Technology" [5]
- Overall success rate is about 25% per cycle of IVF in USA, ~17% in Europe
- Over 80,000 IVF cycles in USA in 2001
- Over 48,000 babies by IVF in 2003 in USA
- With IVF in USA, 36% lead to multiple births per delivery
- About 1% of births are through IVF at the present time
- Overall outcomes of children born through IVF are good
- Complications in children born to IVF mainly related to high birth order
- Slight increase in urogenital malformations present in boys, even in singleton births
- Several different methods for augmenting rates of sperm-egg fertilization [3]
- Gamete intrafallopian transfer - oocytes and sperm placed into fallopian tube
- Zygote intrafallopian transfer - fertilized oocytes placed into fallopian tube
- Tubal embryo transfer - cleaving embryos placed into fallopian tube
- Peritoneal oocyte and sperm transfer - oocytes and sperm placed into pelvic cavity
- Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI, also called sperm extraction; see below)
- Testicular sperm extraction - for azoospermia
- Microsurgical epididymal sperm aspiration - for azoospermia
- Transfer of blastocyst stage superior to cleavage-stage embryos [13]
- Factors Associated with Reduced Success Rates
- Age <25 (slight reduction) and >30 years (increasing failure with age)
- Rate of live births to women <35 years is 40-49% (using woman's own eggs)
- Rate of live births to women 43 years old is ~5%
- Lack of prior pregnancy or live birth
- Increasing number of failed previous cycles
- Male sperm abnormalities
- Increasing duration of infertility
- High Rate of Multiple Births with Standard IVF [21,22]
- In general, more than two embryos are transferred (>1 often fails)
- Multiple births occur in 27-33% of cases (compared with ~1% of controls)
- When >4 eggs are fertizilized and available for transfer, transfer of 2 embryos versus >2 embryos reduces multiple births without reducing overall chance of a birth
- Multiple births lead to increased risk of prematurity and low birth weight [23]
- Slightly higher incidence of low birth weight amongst singleton births [23]
- In women <36 years, transferring one fresh embryo, followed if needed by one frozen- and-thawed embryo reduces in only 0.8% multiple-birth rate [31]
- Transfer of single blastocyst (day 5) versus cleavage-stage (day 3) embryo associated with 32% versus 21% delivery and 0/87 versus 2/87 twin births [13]
- Mild ovarian stimulation using GnRH antagonist combined with single embryo transfer ("mild IVF") gave similar pregnancy and live birth rates, reduced (0.5%) multiple births [15]
- Complications [22,24]
- Ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome (see above) ~5% of IVF situations
- IVF singleton pregnancies have increased complication rates compared with controls
- Very preterm births were ~3.5X more likely with IVF
- Very low birthweight (<1500 gm) were ~2.6-4.4X more likely with IVF [23]
- All and major malformations were ~2.0X and 1.3X more common with IVF versus matched infants born to natural pregnancies
- Overall neurological sequelae risk 1.7X (1.4X for singletons) [25]
- Cerebral palsy risk increased 2.8-3.7X [25]
- Risk of neurologic sequelae of any type largely associated with multiple births [25]
- No increase in childhood cancer in IVF group
- Preimplantation Genetic Screening
- To choose embryos with normal karyotype in patients (with genetic disorders) [32]
- In women age 35-41 without known genetic abnormalities, preimplant genetic screening Is associated with significantly poorer fertily and birth outcomes [35]
L. Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection (ICSI) [2,25,26]
- ICSI is a particularly useful approach for abnormal sperm motility and other sperm abnormalities ("male factor" abnormalities")
- Now used in majority of IVF cycles as it is more efficient than simple egg/sperm coculture 3, Dramatic increases in use over past 12 years, related to state-mandated insurance coverage
- Of successful injections, overall pregnancy rate was 37% for ICSI [25]
- Potential for increased DNA damage on sperm introduction into egg
- Malformations occured ~2.6% but no increase in sex chromosome abnormalities [25]
- No differences in congenital malformations or major health problems at one year
- In another study, 2X risk of major birth defects with ICSI as natural births [24]
- At one year, 17% of children by ICSI versus 2% by IVF had mild developmental delays
- Therefore, children conceived by ICSI may require more careful attention in early years
References
- Evers JL. 2002. Lancet. 360(9327):151

- Smith S, Pfeifer SM, Collins JA. 2003. JAMA. 290(13):1767

- Rosene-Montella K, Keely E, Laifer SA, Lee RV. 2000. Ann Intern Med. 132(12):973

- Hubacher D, Lara-Ricalde R, Taylor DJ, et al. 2001. NEJM. 345(8):561

- Sutcliffe AG and Ludwig M. 2007. Lancet. 370(9584):351

- Guzick DS, Overstreet JW, Factor-Litvak P, et al. 2001. NEJM. 345(19):1388

- Fauser BC, Devroey PK, Macklon NS. 2005. Lancet. 365(9473):1807

- Van Voorhis BJ. 2007. NEJM. 356(4):379

- Evers JLH and Collins JA. 2003. Lancet. 361(9372):1849

- Steures P, van der STeeg JW, Hompes PG, et al. 2006. Lancet. 368(9531):216

- Adashi EY and Hennebold JD. 1999. NEJM. 340(9):709

- Radford JA, Lieberman BA, Brison DR, et al. 2001. Lancet. 357(9263):1172

- Papanikolaou EG, Camus M, Kolibianakis EM, et al. 2006. NEJM. 354(11);1139

- Hunter MH and Sterrett JJ. 2000. Am Fam Phys. 62(5):1079

- Heijnen EM, Eijkemans MJ, De Klerk C, et al. 2007. Lancet. 369(9563):743

- Barratt CL and Publicover SJ. 2001. Lancet. 358(9294):1661
- Guzick DS, Carson SA, Coutifaris C, et al. 1999. NEJM. 340(3):177

- Gleicher N, Oleske DM, Tur-Kaspa I, et al. 2000. NEJM. 343(1):2

- Goverde AJ, McDonnell J, Vermeiden JPW, et al. 2000. Lancet. 355(9197):13

- Beier DR and Dluhy RG. 2003. NEJM. 349(17):1589

- Templeton A and Morris JK. 1998. NEJM. 339(9):573

- Bergh T, Ericson A, Hillensjo T, et al. 1999. Lancet. 354(9190):1579

- Schieve LA, Meikle SF, Ferre C, et al. 2002. NEJM. 346(10):731

- Hansen M, Kurinczuk JJ, Bower C, Webb S. 2002. NEJM. 346(10):725

- Stromberg B, Dahlquist G, Ericson A, et al. 2002. Lancet. 359(9305):461

- Jain T and Gupta RS. 2007. NEJM. 357(3):251

- Vasseur C, Rodien P, Beau I, et al. 2003. NEJM. 349(8):753

- Smits G, Olatunbosun O, Delbaere A, et al. 2003. NEJM. 349(8):760

- Miyamoto T, Hasuike S, Yogev L, et al. 2003. Lancet. 362(9397):1714

- Schlechte JA. 2003. NEJM. 349(21):2035

- Thurin A, Hausken J, Hillensjo T, et al. 2004. 351(23):2392

- Holmes LB, Gargiulo AR, Nadal AS, Racowsky C. 2005. NEJM. 352(15):1579 (Case Record)

- Chan JL and Mantzoros CS. 2005. Lancet. 366(9474):74
- Lobo RA. 2005. NEJM. 353(1):64

- Mastenbroek S, Twisk M, van Echten-Arends J, et al. 2007. NEJM. 357(1):9
