A. Potential Gene Therapy Targets
- Replacement of "Missing" or "Null" Genes
- Replacement of Abnormal Genes (whose products are expressed)
- Gene Therapy of Neoplastic Diseases
- Increase Expression of Desired / Protective Genes
- Drug resistance glycoproteins (such as mdr1/PGP1) in normal cells [3]
- Anti-inflammatory proteins in diseased arthritic joints
- Gene Therapy of AIDS
- Treatment of autoimmune disease
- Gene-based Vaccination [5]
B. Gene Delivery Systems [1,2,3]
- Naked DNA
- Liposomes / Cationic Lipid Mediated Transfer [7]
- Viral vectors are becoming less attractive due to side effect issues
- Retrovirus
- Requires packaging cell line expressing gag, pol and env
- Recipient cells must be proliferating in order to integrate new gene
- Over 300 patients have received retroviral vector-genes with no adverse effects
- Successful prolonged gene expression after ex vivo transfer has been achieved [6]
- Gammaretroviral vector has been used to correct SCID in humans [4,6]
- Adenovirus
- Adeno-Associated Virus (AAV)
- Herpes Simplex Virus (HSV) Type 1
- Adenovirus Coat Protein
- Delivery may be ex vivo or in vivo
- Major problem in all areas of gene therapy is immune responses to vectors
C. Correction of Recessive Genetic Mutations
- These are theoretically the easiest to correct
- Most of these disorders are monogenic recessive
- Even if abnormal gene is expressed, it does not interfere with normal protein function
- Normal (replacement) gene needs to be transferred into cell and expressed
- No specific insertion site (into genome) will be required
- Examples
- Severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID): autosomal and X-linked forms
- X-Linked SCID: defects in gene encoding common cytokine receptor gamma chain [4]
- Autosomal SCID: adenosine deaminase deficiency
- Factor VIII deficiency
- Hypercholesterolemia
- Other immunodeficiency diseases are being evaluated
- Specific Gene Regulation
- Many genes can be expressed at ectopic sites and will function, improve symptoms
- However, some genes will have to be expressed in appropriate tissues at a given time
- ß-globin expression, abnormal thalassemia, requires cell and temporal specificity
- Cystic fibrosis gene transfer (CFTR) is under intensive study [7,8]
- alpha1-antitrypsin deficiency (panacinar emphysema) is also being studied [8]
- Correction of X-Linked SCID [4,6]
- Ex vivo gene transfer with defective retroviral vector achieved
- Common gamma chain gene expression >2.5 years after transfected CD34+ cells infused
- Thymopoiesis, T and B lymphocytes documented
- Peripheral T cell show T cell receptor diversity
- B-cells matured and produced increasing rates of somatically mutated immunoglobulin (Ig)
- Serum Ig levels restored to level sufficient to avoid IV Ig treatments in some patients
- Vaccination stimulated antibody production
D. Correction of Dominant Genetic Mutations
- Abnormal gene products are expressed and may interfere with normal gene products
- If there is interference with normal function, the disorder is usually dominant
- If there is no interference with normal function, the disorder is recessive
- For dominant mutations, actual replacement of the abnormal gene may be required
- Specific disruption of abnormal gene by transferred normal gene may be required
- Such targetted gene replacement therapies may be difficult
- The technology for this "homologous recombinantion" exists but is not efficient
- Examples: sickle cell anemia, familial retinoblastoma (abnormal RB protein)
- In sickle cell anemia, the abnormal hemoglobin, HbSS, interferes with normal function
- If high enough normal Hb (HbA) can be achieved, then symptoms may be reduced
- Heteromeric Hb molecules should reduce symptoms
E. Gene Therapy of Cancer [6,8]
- Introduction of drug susceptibility ("suicide") genes into cancer cells
- Introduction of normal p53 genes into tumor cells having abnormal p53
- This should enhance tumor response to radiation and/or chemotherapy
- Introduction of herpes thymidine kinase gene to tumors makes susceptible to ganciclovir
- HSVtk metabolism of ganciclovir leads to bystander killing by diffusion of toxic metabolites, thus potentially enhancing activity
- Introduction of Immune enhancing molecules into the tumor cells
- Expression of major histocompatibility proteins (MHC)
- Increased MHC proteins on a subset of tumor cells may increase immunogenicity
- Expression of T cell coactivation molecules on the tumor cells
- This may allow tumor cells themselves to act as immune accessory cells
- Expression of cytokine genes in the tumor cells
- Expression of specific cytokine genes in lymphocytes and other cells in cancer patients
- Introduction of chemotherapy-protecting genes into normal cells
- Introduction of drug resistance (eg. mdr-1) genes into normal hematopoietic cells
- Use with autologous bone marrow transplantation during/after high dose chemotherapy
- Genetic markers such as neo resistance gene can be used to follow specific cell homing
- This is useful in animal models of tumor cell metastates
- Has been empolyed to follow TIL and CTL cells in therapy of cancer patients
- Gene marking demonstrated tumor cell reinfusion in bone marrow transplant
F. Muscle Mediated Gene Therapy [9]
- Muscle cells can be manipulated fairly easly for gene expression
- Muscle biopsy explants will give rise to myoblasts in culture
- Naked (eg. plasmid) DNA injected into muscle will be taken up and genes expressed
- Naked DNA injected into muscle may make ideal vaccination methods
- These cells can be infected with retrovirus containing gene of interest
- Gene expression is very efficient in these cells
- Post-translational modifications are generally carried out correctly
- Myoblasts expressing recombinant protein can be reinjected into human muscle [10]
- Injected myoblasts fuse into the host muscle fibers
- This process is fairly efficient, including gene expression from the fiber
- Proteins secreted from the fibers enter recipient's bloodstream
G. Cystc Fibrosis [7,11,12]
- Mutations in the CFTR gene lead to malfunctioning transport protein
- Most of the CFTR mutations appear to be recessive
- Adenoviral vectors carrying normal CFTR cDNA have been used for transfer
- Major problem at present is immune response to viral proteins expressed on infected cells
- Modifications of the viral vectors is currently a major focus of research
- Whether CFTR can be targetted with adenovirus to pancreas and other organs is not clear
H. Cardiovascular Disease [13]
- Development of collateral blood vessels
- Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF)
- Fibroblast Growth Factor ß (FGFß)
- Particularly for myocardial ischemia and peripheral vascular disease
- Anti-Angiogenesis Therapy
- Blockade of restenosis (after angioplasty) and vein graft thickening
- Local delivery of a variety of agents is preferred
I. Gene-Based Vaccines [5]
- DNA and other gene-based vaccines under development
- Designed to generate both cellular and humoral (antibody) immune responses
- Live versus naked DNA vector systems being investigated
- Plasmid DNA vaccines are probably safe and stimulate good immunity
- Mixed modality vaccines also under development
References
- Ratko TA, Cummings JP, Blebea J, Matuszewski KA. 2003. Am J Med. 115(7):560
- Hanania EG, Kavanagh J, Hortobagyi G, et al. 1995. Am J Med. 99(5):537
- Brenner MK. 1996. NEJM. 335(5):340
- Gaspar HB, Parsley KL, Howe S, et al. 2004. Lancet. 364(9452):2181
- Srivastava IK and Liu MA. 2003. Ann Intern Med. 138(7):550
- Hacein-Bey-Abina S, Le Deist F, Carlier F, et al. 2002. NEJM. 346(16):1185
- Alton EWFW, Stern M, Farley R, et al. 1999. Lancet. 353:947
- Albelda SM, Wiewrodt R, Zuckerman JB. 2000. Ann Intern Med. 132(8):649
- Blau HM and Springer ML. 1995. NEJM. 333(23):1554
- Mendell JR, Kissel JT, Amato AA, et al. 1995. NEJM. 333(13):832
- Knowles MR, Hohneker KW, Zhou Z, et al. 1995. NEJM. 333(13):823
- Schwiebert EM, Benos DJ, Fuller CM. 1998. Am J Med. 104(6):576
- Yla-Herttuala S and Martin JF. 2000. Lancet. 355(9199):213