Differential Diagnosis of Musculoskeletal Disorders
= decrease in bone quantity maintaining normal quality
- increased radiolucency of bone:
- vertical striations in vertebral bodies
- accentuation of tensile + compressive trabeculae of proximal femur
- reinforcement lines (= bone bars) crossing marrow cavity about knee
- cortical resorption of 2nd metacarpal:
- measuring outer cortical diameter (W) and width of medullary cavity (m) at mid portion of bone and reporting combined cortical thickness (CCT = W + m)
- subperiosteal tunneling
Categories:
- DIFFUSE OSTEOPENIA
- Osteoporosis = decreased osteoid production
- Osteomalacia = undermineralization of osteoid
- Hyperparathyroidism
- Multiple myeloma / diffuse metastases
- Drugs
- Mastocytosis
- Osteogenesis imperfecta
- REGIONAL OSTEOPENIA
Osteoporosis
= reduced bone mass of normal composition secondary to
- osteoclastic resorption (85%): trabecular, endosteal, intracortical, subperiosteal
- osteocytic resorption (15%)
- Prevalence: 7% of all women aged 3540 years; 12% for males + females aged 5079 years; ◊ Most common of all metabolic bone disorders; 14 million worldwide by 2020
Classification:
- Primary / involutional osteoporosis ← cumulative bone loss as people age and undergo sex hormone changes
- Type I (postmenopausal) osteoporosis
= accelerated trabecular bone resorption ← estrogen deficiency
Fracture pattern: spine and wrist - Type II (senile) osteoporosis
= proportionate loss of cortical and trabecular bone
Fracture pattern: hip, proximal humerus, tibia, pelvis
- Secondary osteoporosis (in 2030%) = consequence of various medical conditions / use of certain medications
Etiology:
- CONGENITAL DISORDERS
- Osteogenesis imperfecta
- The only osteoporosis with bending of bones!
- Homocystinuria
- IDIOPATHIC (bone loss begins earlier + proceeds more rapidly in women)
1. Juvenile osteoporosis: | <20 years | 2. Adult osteoporosis: | 2040 years | 3. Postmenopausal osteoporosis: (4050% lower trabecular bone mineral density in elderly than in young women) | >50 years | 4. Senile osteoporosis: progressively decreasing bone density at a rate of 8% (3%) in females (males) per year | >60 years |
|
- NUTRITIONAL DISTURBANCES
scurvy; calcium deficiency; protein deficiency (nephrosis, chronic liver disease, alcoholism, anorexia nervosa, kwashiorkor, starvation, malnutrition, malabsorption) - ENDOCRINOPATHY
Cushing disease, hypogonadism (Turner syndrome, eunuchoidism), hyperthyroidism, hyperparathyroidism, acromegaly, Addison disease, diabetes mellitus, pregnancy, paraneoplastic phenomenon in liver tumors - RENAL OSTEODYSTROPHY
decrease / same / increase in spinal trabecular bone; rapid loss in appendicular skeleton - IMMOBILIZATION = disuse osteoporosis
- COLLAGEN DISEASE, RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
- BONE MARROW REPLACEMENT
infiltration by lymphoma / leukemia (ALL), multiple myeloma, diffuse metastases, marrow hyperplasia ← hemolytic anemia - DRUG THERAPY
corticosteroids, heparin (15,00030,000 U for >6 months), methotrexate, excessive alcohol consumption, smoking, Dilantin, aromatase inhibitors, gonadotropin-releasing hormone antagonist - RADIATION THERAPY
- LOCALIZED OSTEOPOROSIS
immobilization / disuse, Sudeck dystrophy, transient osteoporosis of large joints, regional migratory osteoporosis of lower extremities
- serum calcium, phosphorus, alkaline phosphatase frequently normal
- hydroxyproline may be elevated during acute stage
Significant predictors of osteoporotic fractures:
- Age
- History of fracture
- Failed chair test (= inability to rise from a chair in 3 successions without using arms)
- Fall within past 12 months
Clinical manifestation:
- Vertebral compression fracture (HALLMARK)
- Femoral fracture: neck + intertrochanteric region
- Fracture of distal radius (Colles) and tibia
Technique of Bone Densitometry:
- Single-Photon Absorptiometry
measures primarily cortical bone of appendicular bones, single-energy 125I radioisotope source
Site: distal radius (= wrist bone density), os calcis
Dose: 23 mrem
Precision: 13% - Dual-Photon Absorptiometry
radioactive energy source with 2 photon peaks; should be reserved for patients <65 years of age because of interference from osteophytosis + vascular calcifications
Site: vertebrae, femoral neck
Dose: 510 mrem
Precision: 24% - Single X-ray Absorptiometry
= area projectional technique for quantitative bone density measurement
Site: distal radius, calcaneus
Dose: low
Precision: 0.52% - Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DXA / DEXA)
= quantitative digital radiography
- Most widely used & most precise technique!
- Standard of reference for diagnosis of osteoporosis in conjunction with Fracture Risk Assessment Tool at http://www.shef.ac.uk/FRAX/ for results of a 10-year probability of a major osteoporotic fracture in hip, spine, proximal humerus, distal forearm
Technique:- mobile x-ray source composed of 2 different photon energy levels (constant + pulsed) moves together with detection system
- rectilinear / fan-beam scanners
- attenuation values of soft tissues are subtracted, leaving only the attenuation values of bone
- lateral scanning of spine increases accuracy without superimposition of posterior elements + marginal osteophytes + vascular calcifications
Advantage:- low radiation dose with higher radiation flux than radioisotope source of dual-photon absorptiometry
- uses sites where osteoporotic fractures occur
- low cost; ease of use; rapidity of measurement
Limitation of 2-dimensional (areal) technique:- no distinction between cortical + trabecular bone
- no discrimination between changes secondary to bone geometry + increased bone density
- regulatory oversight for ionizing radiation
Site:- lumbar spine (L1L4)
- proximal femur (total hip, femoral neck, trochanter, Ward area)
- calcaneus (95% trabecular bone)
- forearm (suboptimal ← mostly cortical bone)
Dose:<3 mrem
Precision: 12%
Data collected:
- BMD (bone marrow density) value (g/cm2)
- T-score = how far is the score from the mean of 50 with a SD of 10 compared with young adults 2030 years of age (= peak of bone mass)
- Z-score = location of a score compared to age-matched + gender-matched controls in a distribution with a mean of 0 and a SD of 1.0; particularly important in patients aged >75 years
Interpretation:
- normal (≥1.0); osteopenia (<1.0 but >2.5); osteoporosis (≤2.5); severe osteoporosis (≤2.5 with a fragility fracture)
Pitfalls:
- weekly phantom calibration to detect scanner drift
- improper patient positioning (decentering of lumbar spine, abduction / external rotation of hip)
- improper numbering of vertebrae, placement of intervertebral markers, detection of bone edges
- blurring / irregular contour of bone margins ← patient motion
- anatomic artifacts from
- superimposed disease: degenerative disk disease, compression fracture, postsurgical defect, overlying atherosclerotic calcifications
- implanted devices: stent + vena cava filter, GI barium, hardware, vertebroplasty cement
- external objects: piercing, bra clips, metallic buttons
- Results from different scanners not interchangeable ← differences in scanners and software programs
- Quantitative Computed Tomography
= determines true volumetric density (mg/cm3) by providing separate estimates of trabecular + cortical bone BMD over 24 vertebrae (T12L4)
- high-turnover cancellous bone is important for vertebral strength and has high responsiveness
- trabecular bone + low-turnover compact bone can be measured separately
Advantage:- allows separate analysis of trabeculae + cortices
- selective assessment of metabolically active trabecular bone in center of vertebral body
- better sensitivity than projectional methods (DXA)
- exclusion of structures not contributing to spine mechanical resistance
Disadvantage:- high radiation dose
- poor precision limited to longitudinal assessment
- high costs
- high degree of operator dependence
- need for considerable amount of space
- limited scanner access
Pitfalls affecting measurements:- myelofibrosis + hematopoietic disorders + fat
Technique:- use of low-dose commercial CT scanner
- compared to external bone mineral reference phantom that is scanned simultaneously with patient to calibrate CT attenuation measurements
- 10-mmthick section with gantry angle correction through center of vertebral body
- results expressed as absolute values / Z and T scores
Site: vertebrae L1L3, other sites
Use: assessment of vertebral fracture risk; measurement of age-related bone loss; follow-up of osteoporosis + metabolic bone disease
- single energy: 300500 mrem; 625% precision
- dual energy: 750800 mrem; 510% precision
◊Most sensitive technique! - Peripheral Quantitative CT
= exact 3-dimensional localization of target volumes with multisection data acquisition capability covering a large volume of bone
Site: distal radius - Quantitative Heel Ultrasound
= determines US stiffness index(SI) using formula
SI = 0.67 BUA [dB/MHz] + 0.28 SOS [m/s] 420 SOS = speed of sound BUA = broadband ultrasound attenuation for 200600 kHz
as a risk assessment independent from DEXA
◊Fracture risk increases with decrease in SI
Precision: 2.2%
Disadvantage: lack of sensitivity, equipment drift
Location: axial skeleton (lower dorsal + lumbar spine), proximal humerus, neck of femur, wrist, ribs
Radiographs:
- Radiographs: insensitive prior to bone loss of 2530%
- Bone scans do NOT show a diffuse increase in activity
- increased radiolucency = decreased number + thickness of trabeculae = osteopenia (poverty of bone):
- relatively prominent primary trabeculae ← initially selective loss of secondary trabeculae
- juxtaarticular osteopenia with trabecular bone predominance (eg, distal radius + proximal femur):
- accentuation of compressive + tensile trabeculae
- sparsely trabeculated region in inferomedial femoral neck between converging primary and secondary compressive groups = Ward triangle
- Trabecular bone responds to metabolic changes faster than cortical bone
- cortical thinning (endosteal + intracortical + periosteal resorption):
- scalloping of inner cortical margin
- widening of marrow canal
- prominent longitudinal cortical striations = tunneling
- irregular definition of outer bone surface
- Most specific finding of high bone turnover
- delayed fracture healing with poor callus formation (DDx: abundant callus formation in osteogenesis imperfecta + Cushing syndrome)
Cx: fracture for 1÷2 women + 1÷4 men >age 50 years
- Fractures at sites rich in labile trabecular bone (eg, vertebrae, wrist) in postmenopausal osteoporosis
- Fractures at sites containing cortical + trabecular bone (eg, hip) in senile osteoporosis
Rx: calcitonin, sodium fluoride, diphosphonates, parathyroid hormone supplements, estrogen replacement
Osteoporosis of Spine
Clinical manifestation:
- vertebral compression fracture occurring
- spontaneously
- during lifting / bending / coughing
- load simply caused by muscle contraction
- progressive loss of stature → shortening of paraspinal musculature requiring prolonged active contraction for maintenance of posture → pain from muscle fatigue
Location: thoracolumbar junction (T12, L1), midthoracic area (T7, T8)
- diminished radiographic density
- vertical striations = rarefaction of trabeculae ← marked thinning of secondary horizontal (transverse) trabeculae + relative accentuation of primary vertical trabeculae along lines of stress
- accentuation of endplates
- picture framing (= accentuation of cortical outline with preservation of external dimensions ← endosteal + intracortical resorption
- anterior wedge fracture resulting in spinal deformity:
- kyphosis ← multiple fractures in 2030%
- The greater the degree of osteoporosis the greater the number of fractures!
- dowager's hump
- reduction in thoracic and abdominal space →
- impaired pulmonary function
- protuberant abdomen
- alteration in body shape
- endplate fracture = compression deformity with reduction in mid height + protrusion of intervertebral disks:
- biconcavity of vertebra
- Schmorl nodes
- crush fracture = reduction of overall height of a vertebra relative to adjacent vertebrae:
- height loss >4 mm (posterior height is normally 13 mm more than anterior height for thoracic vertebra)
- decreased height of vertebrae → loss of body height
- absence of osteophytes
- MR:
- heterogeneously hyperintense SI on T1WI:
- focal fatty marrow usually has a round morphology
- round lesions coalesce to involve entire vertebral body
- variable T2 signal intensity
Osteoporosis of Appendicular Skeleton
- Hand (on industrial hard-copy film)
- corticomedullary index = evaluation of cortical thickness of 2nd metacarpal bone
- Digital X-ray Radiogrammetry (DXR)
- = digitized PA radiograph with automatic segmentation of cortex + medulla of midshafts of 2nd + 3rd + 4th metacarpal bones → average cortical thickness + average bone width in region of interest
- Advantage: high reproducibility; capacity to predict future fracture; widely available; inexpensive; low radiation dose
- Femur
- Singh classification system = trabeculae in proximal femur disappear in predictable sequence
- Calcaneus
- Jhamaria index = lateral radiograph of calcaneus
Osteomalacia
= accumulation of excessive amounts of uncalcified osteoid with bone softening + insufficient mineralization of osteoid due to
- high remodeling rate: excessive osteoid formation + normal / little mineralization
- low remodeling rate: normal osteoid production + diminished mineralization
Etiology:
- dietary deficiency of vitamin D3 + lack of solar irradiation
- deficient metabolism of vitamin D:
- chronic renal tubular disease
- chronic administration of phenobarbital (alternate liver pathway)
- diphenylhydantoin (interferes with vitamin D action on bowel)
- decreased absorption of vitamin D:
- malabsorption syndromes (most common)
- partial gastrectomy (self-restriction of fatty foods)
- diminished deposition of calcium in bone
- diphosphonates (for treatment of Paget disease)
Histo: excess of osteoid seams + decreased appositional rate
- bone pain / tenderness; muscular weakness
- serum calcium slightly low / normal
- decreased serum phosphorus
- elevated serum alkaline phosphatase
- uniform osteopenia
- fuzzy indistinct trabecular detail of endosteal surface
- coarsened frayed trabeculae decreased in number + size
- thin cortices of long bone
- bone deformity from softening:
- hourglass thorax
- bowing of long bones
- acetabular protrusion
- buckled / compressed pelvis
- biconcave vertebral bodies
- increased incidence of insufficiency fractures
- pseudofractures = Looser zones
- mottled skull
Localized / Regional Osteopenia
- Disuse osteoporosis / atrophy
Etiology: local immobilization secondary to
- fracture (more pronounced distal to fracture site)
- neural paralysis
- muscular paralysis
- Reflex sympathetic dystrophy = Sudeck dystrophy
- Regional migratory osteoporosis, transient regional osteoporosis of hip
- Rheumatologic disorders
- Infection: osteomyelitis, tuberculosis
- Osteolytic tumor
- Lytic phase of Paget disease
- Early phase of bone infarct and hemorrhage
- Burns + frostbite
Bone Marrow Edema
= hypointense on T1WI + hyperintense on T2WI relative to fatty marrow
- Trauma
- bone bruise
- radiographically occult acute fracture
- recent surgery
- Infection = osteomyelitis
- Aseptic arthritis
- Osteonecrosis = early stage of AVN
- Neuropathic osteoarthropathy
- Reflex sympathetic dystrophy (some cases)
- Transient osteoporosis of hip
- Infiltrative neoplasm
Transverse Lucent Metaphyseal Lines
mnemonic: LINING
- Leukemia
- Illness, systemic (rickets, scurvy)
- Normal variant
- Infection, transplacental (congenital syphilis)
- Neuroblastoma metastases
- Growth lines
Frayed Metaphyses
mnemonic: CHARMS
- Congenital infections (rubella, syphilis)
- Hypophosphatasia
- Achondroplasia
- Rickets
- Metaphyseal dysostosis
- Scurvy
Outline