section name header

Information

Differential Diagnosis of Musculoskeletal Disorders

= decrease in bone quantity maintaining normal quality

Categories:

  1. DIFFUSE OSTEOPENIA
    1. Osteoporosis = decreased osteoid production
    2. Osteomalacia = undermineralization of osteoid
    3. Hyperparathyroidism
    4. Multiple myeloma / diffuse metastases
    5. Drugs
    6. Mastocytosis
    7. Osteogenesis imperfecta
  2. REGIONAL OSTEOPENIA

Osteoporosis!!navigator!!

= reduced bone mass of normal composition secondary to

  1. osteoclastic resorption (85%): trabecular, endosteal, intracortical, subperiosteal
  2. osteocytic resorption (15%)
  • Prevalence: 7% of all women aged 35–40 years; 12% for males + females aged 50–79 years; Most common of all metabolic bone disorders; 14 million worldwide by 2020

Classification:

  1. Primary / involutional osteoporosis cumulative bone loss as people age and undergo sex hormone changes
    1. Type I (postmenopausal) osteoporosis
      = accelerated trabecular bone resorption estrogen deficiency
      Fracture pattern: spine and wrist
    2. Type II (senile) osteoporosis
      = proportionate loss of cortical and trabecular bone
      Fracture pattern: hip, proximal humerus, tibia, pelvis
  2. Secondary osteoporosis (in 20–30%) = consequence of various medical conditions / use of certain medications

Etiology:

  1. CONGENITAL DISORDERS
    1. Osteogenesis imperfecta
      • The only osteoporosis with bending of bones!
    2. Homocystinuria
  2. IDIOPATHIC (bone loss begins earlier + proceeds more rapidly in women)
    1. Juvenile osteoporosis:<20 years
    2. Adult osteoporosis:20–40 years
    3. Postmenopausal osteoporosis:
    (40–50% lower trabecular bone mineral density in elderly than in young women)
    >50 years
    4. Senile osteoporosis:
    progressively decreasing bone density at a rate of 8% (3%) in females (males) per year
    >60 years
  3. NUTRITIONAL DISTURBANCES
    scurvy; calcium deficiency; protein deficiency (nephrosis, chronic liver disease, alcoholism, anorexia nervosa, kwashiorkor, starvation, malnutrition, malabsorption)
  4. ENDOCRINOPATHY
    Cushing disease, hypogonadism (Turner syndrome, eunuchoidism), hyperthyroidism, hyperparathyroidism, acromegaly, Addison disease, diabetes mellitus, pregnancy, paraneoplastic phenomenon in liver tumors
  5. RENAL OSTEODYSTROPHY
    decrease / same / increase in spinal trabecular bone; rapid loss in appendicular skeleton
  6. IMMOBILIZATION = disuse osteoporosis
  7. COLLAGEN DISEASE, RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS
  8. BONE MARROW REPLACEMENT
    infiltration by lymphoma / leukemia (ALL), multiple myeloma, diffuse metastases, marrow hyperplasia hemolytic anemia
  9. DRUG THERAPY
    corticosteroids, heparin (15,000–30,000 U for >6 months), methotrexate, excessive alcohol consumption, smoking, Dilantin, aromatase inhibitors, gonadotropin-releasing hormone antagonist
  10. RADIATION THERAPY
  11. LOCALIZED OSTEOPOROSIS
    immobilization / disuse, Sudeck dystrophy, transient osteoporosis of large joints, regional migratory osteoporosis of lower extremities
  • serum calcium, phosphorus, alkaline phosphatase frequently normal
  • hydroxyproline may be elevated during acute stage

Significant predictors of osteoporotic fractures:

  1. Age
  2. History of fracture
  3. Failed chair test (= inability to rise from a chair in 3 successions without using arms)
  4. Fall within past 12 months

Clinical manifestation:

  1. Vertebral compression fracture (HALLMARK)
  2. Femoral fracture: neck + intertrochanteric region
  3. Fracture of distal radius (Colles) and tibia

Technique of Bone Densitometry:

  1. Single-Photon Absorptiometry
    measures primarily cortical bone of appendicular bones, single-energy 125I radioisotope source
    Site: distal radius (= wrist bone density), os calcis
    Dose: 2–3 mrem
    Precision: 1–3%
  2. Dual-Photon Absorptiometry
    radioactive energy source with 2 photon peaks; should be reserved for patients <65 years of age because of interference from osteophytosis + vascular calcifications
    Site: vertebrae, femoral neck
    Dose: 5–10 mrem
    Precision: 2–4%
  3. Single X-ray Absorptiometry
    = area projectional technique for quantitative bone density measurement
    Site: distal radius, calcaneus
    Dose: low
    Precision: 0.5–2%
  4. Dual Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DXA / DEXA)
    = quantitative digital radiography
    • Most widely used & most precise technique!
    • Standard of reference for diagnosis of osteoporosis in conjunction with Fracture Risk Assessment Tool at http://www.shef.ac.uk/FRAX/ for results of a 10-year probability of a major osteoporotic fracture in hip, spine, proximal humerus, distal forearm

    Technique:
    • mobile x-ray source composed of 2 different photon energy levels (constant + pulsed) moves together with detection system
    • rectilinear / fan-beam scanners
    • attenuation values of soft tissues are subtracted, leaving only the attenuation values of bone
    • lateral scanning of spine increases accuracy without superimposition of posterior elements + marginal osteophytes + vascular calcifications

    Advantage:
    1. low radiation dose with higher radiation flux than radioisotope source of dual-photon absorptiometry
    2. uses sites where osteoporotic fractures occur
    3. low cost; ease of use; rapidity of measurement

    Limitation of 2-dimensional (areal) technique:
    1. no distinction between cortical + trabecular bone
    2. no discrimination between changes secondary to bone geometry + increased bone density
    3. regulatory oversight for ionizing radiation

    Site:
    1. lumbar spine (L1–L4)
    2. proximal femur (total hip, femoral neck, trochanter, Ward area)
    3. calcaneus (95% trabecular bone)
    4. forearm (suboptimal mostly cortical bone)

    Dose:<3 mrem
    Precision: 1–2%
    Data collected:
    • BMD (bone marrow density) value (g/cm2)
    • T-score = how far is the score from the mean of 50 with a SD of 10 compared with young adults 20–30 years of age (= peak of bone mass)
    • Z-score = location of a score compared to age-matched + gender-matched controls in a distribution with a mean of 0 and a SD of 1.0; particularly important in patients aged >75 years

    Interpretation:
    • normal (–1.0); osteopenia (<–1.0 but >–2.5); osteoporosis (–2.5); severe osteoporosis (–2.5 with a fragility fracture)

    Pitfalls:
    • weekly phantom calibration to detect scanner drift
    • improper patient positioning (decentering of lumbar spine, abduction / external rotation of hip)
    • improper numbering of vertebrae, placement of intervertebral markers, detection of bone edges
    • blurring / irregular contour of bone margins patient motion
    • anatomic artifacts from
      1. superimposed disease: degenerative disk disease, compression fracture, postsurgical defect, overlying atherosclerotic calcifications
      2. implanted devices: stent + vena cava filter, GI barium, hardware, vertebroplasty cement
      3. external objects: piercing, bra clips, metallic buttons
    • Results from different scanners not interchangeable differences in scanners and software programs
  5. Quantitative Computed Tomography
    = determines true volumetric density (mg/cm3) by providing separate estimates of trabecular + cortical bone BMD over 2–4 vertebrae (T12–L4)
    • high-turnover cancellous bone is important for vertebral strength and has high responsiveness
    • trabecular bone + low-turnover compact bone can be measured separately

    Advantage:
    • allows separate analysis of trabeculae + cortices
    • selective assessment of metabolically active trabecular bone in center of vertebral body
    • better sensitivity than projectional methods (DXA)
    • exclusion of structures not contributing to spine mechanical resistance

    Disadvantage:
    • high radiation dose
    • poor precision limited to longitudinal assessment
    • high costs
    • high degree of operator dependence
    • need for considerable amount of space
    • limited scanner access

    Pitfalls affecting measurements:
    • myelofibrosis + hematopoietic disorders + fat

    Technique:
    • use of low-dose commercial CT scanner
    • compared to external bone mineral reference phantom that is scanned simultaneously with patient to calibrate CT attenuation measurements
    • 10-mm–thick section with gantry angle correction through center of vertebral body
    • results expressed as absolute values / Z and T scores

    Site: vertebrae L1–L3, other sites
    Use: assessment of vertebral fracture risk; measurement of age-related bone loss; follow-up of osteoporosis + metabolic bone disease
    1. single energy: 300–500 mrem; 6–25% precision
    2. dual energy: 750–800 mrem; 5–10% precision

    Most sensitive technique!
  6. Peripheral Quantitative CT
    = exact 3-dimensional localization of target volumes with multisection data acquisition capability covering a large volume of bone
    Site: distal radius
  7. Quantitative Heel Ultrasound
    = determines US stiffness index(SI) using formula
    SI = 0.67 • BUA [dB/MHz] + 0.28 • SOS [m/s] – 420 SOS = speed of sound BUA = broadband ultrasound attenuation for 200–600 kHz
    as a risk assessment independent from DEXA
    Fracture risk increases with decrease in SI
    Precision: 2.2%
    Disadvantage: lack of sensitivity, equipment drift
    Location: axial skeleton (lower dorsal + lumbar spine), proximal humerus, neck of femur, wrist, ribs
    Radiographs:
    • Radiographs: insensitive prior to bone loss of 25–30%
    • Bone scans do NOT show a diffuse increase in activity
    • increased radiolucency = decreased number + thickness of trabeculae = osteopenia (“poverty of bone”):
      • relatively prominent primary trabeculae initially selective loss of secondary trabeculae
      • juxtaarticular osteopenia with trabecular bone predominance (eg, distal radius + proximal femur):
        • accentuation of compressive + tensile trabeculae
        • sparsely trabeculated region in inferomedial femoral neck between converging primary and secondary compressive groups = Ward triangle
      • Trabecular bone responds to metabolic changes faster than cortical bone
    • cortical thinning (endosteal + intracortical + periosteal resorption):
      • scalloping of inner cortical margin
      • widening of marrow canal
      • prominent longitudinal cortical striations = tunneling
      • irregular definition of outer bone surface
        • Most specific finding of high bone turnover
    • delayed fracture healing with poor callus formation (DDx: abundant callus formation in osteogenesis imperfecta + Cushing syndrome)

    Cx: fracture for 1÷2 women + 1÷4 men >age 50 years
    1. Fractures at sites rich in labile trabecular bone (eg, vertebrae, wrist) in postmenopausal osteoporosis
    2. Fractures at sites containing cortical + trabecular bone (eg, hip) in senile osteoporosis

    Rx: calcitonin, sodium fluoride, diphosphonates, parathyroid hormone supplements, estrogen replacement

Osteoporosis of Spine

Clinical manifestation:

  • vertebral compression fracture occurring
    1. spontaneously
    2. during lifting / bending / coughing
    3. load simply caused by muscle contraction
  • progressive loss of stature shortening of paraspinal musculature requiring prolonged active contraction for maintenance of posture pain from muscle fatigue

Location: thoracolumbar junction (T12, L1), midthoracic area (T7, T8)

  • diminished radiographic density
  • vertical striations = rarefaction of trabeculae marked thinning of secondary horizontal (transverse) trabeculae + relative accentuation of primary vertical trabeculae along lines of stress
  • accentuation of endplates
  • “picture framing” (= accentuation of cortical outline with preservation of external dimensions endosteal + intracortical resorption
  • anterior wedge fracture resulting in spinal deformity:
    • kyphosis multiple fractures in 20–30%
      • The greater the degree of osteoporosis the greater the number of fractures!
    • “dowager's hump”
    • reduction in thoracic and abdominal space
      • impaired pulmonary function
      • protuberant abdomen
      • alteration in body shape
  • endplate fracture = compression deformity with reduction in mid height + protrusion of intervertebral disks:
    • biconcavity of vertebra
    • Schmorl nodes
  • crush fracture = reduction of overall height of a vertebra relative to adjacent vertebrae:
    • height loss >4 mm (posterior height is normally 1–3 mm more than anterior height for thoracic vertebra)
  • decreased height of vertebrae loss of body height
  • absence of osteophytes
  • MR:
    • heterogeneously hyperintense SI on T1WI:
      • focal fatty marrow usually has a round morphology
      • round lesions coalesce to involve entire vertebral body
    • variable T2 signal intensity

Osteoporosis of Appendicular Skeleton

  • Hand (on industrial hard-copy film)
    • corticomedullary index = evaluation of cortical thickness of 2nd metacarpal bone
    • Digital X-ray Radiogrammetry (DXR)
      • = digitized PA radiograph with automatic segmentation of cortex + medulla of midshafts of 2nd + 3rd + 4th metacarpal bones average cortical thickness + average bone width in region of interest
      • Advantage: high reproducibility; capacity to predict future fracture; widely available; inexpensive; low radiation dose
  • Femur
    • Singh classification system = trabeculae in proximal femur disappear in predictable sequence
  • Calcaneus
    • Jhamaria index = lateral radiograph of calcaneus

Osteomalacia!!navigator!!

= accumulation of excessive amounts of uncalcified osteoid with bone softening + insufficient mineralization of osteoid due to

  1. high remodeling rate: excessive osteoid formation + normal / little mineralization
  2. low remodeling rate: normal osteoid production + diminished mineralization

Etiology:

  1. dietary deficiency of vitamin D3 + lack of solar irradiation
  2. deficient metabolism of vitamin D:
    • chronic renal tubular disease
    • chronic administration of phenobarbital (alternate liver pathway)
    • diphenylhydantoin (interferes with vitamin D action on bowel)
  3. decreased absorption of vitamin D:
    • malabsorption syndromes (most common)
    • partial gastrectomy (self-restriction of fatty foods)
  4. diminished deposition of calcium in bone
    • diphosphonates (for treatment of Paget disease)

Histo: excess of osteoid seams + decreased appositional rate

  • bone pain / tenderness; muscular weakness
  • serum calcium slightly low / normal
  • decreased serum phosphorus
  • elevated serum alkaline phosphatase
  • uniform osteopenia
  • fuzzy indistinct trabecular detail of endosteal surface
  • coarsened frayed trabeculae decreased in number + size
  • thin cortices of long bone
  • bone deformity from softening:
    • hourglass thorax
    • bowing of long bones
    • acetabular protrusion
    • buckled / compressed pelvis
    • biconcave vertebral bodies
  • increased incidence of insufficiency fractures
  • pseudofractures = Looser zones
  • mottled skull

Localized / Regional Osteopenia!!navigator!!

  1. Disuse osteoporosis / atrophy
    Etiology: local immobilization secondary to
    1. fracture (more pronounced distal to fracture site)
    2. neural paralysis
    3. muscular paralysis
  2. Reflex sympathetic dystrophy = Sudeck dystrophy
  3. Regional migratory osteoporosis, transient regional osteoporosis of hip
  4. Rheumatologic disorders
  5. Infection: osteomyelitis, tuberculosis
  6. Osteolytic tumor
  7. Lytic phase of Paget disease
  8. Early phase of bone infarct and hemorrhage
  9. Burns + frostbite

Bone Marrow Edema!!navigator!!

= hypointense on T1WI + hyperintense on T2WI relative to fatty marrow

  1. Trauma
    1. “bone bruise”
    2. radiographically occult acute fracture
    3. recent surgery
  2. Infection = osteomyelitis
  3. Aseptic arthritis
  4. Osteonecrosis = early stage of AVN
  5. Neuropathic osteoarthropathy
  6. Reflex sympathetic dystrophy (some cases)
  7. Transient osteoporosis of hip
  8. Infiltrative neoplasm

Transverse Lucent Metaphyseal Lines!!navigator!!

mnemonic: LINING

  • Leukemia
  • Illness, systemic (rickets, scurvy)
  • Normal variant
  • Infection, transplacental (congenital syphilis)
  • Neuroblastoma metastases
  • Growth lines

Frayed Metaphyses!!navigator!!

mnemonic: CHARMS

  • Congenital infections (rubella, syphilis)
  • Hypophosphatasia
  • Achondroplasia
  • Rickets
  • Metaphyseal dysostosis
  • Scurvy

Outline