For urine incontinence, diapers may be the most cost-effective disposable design for men both day and night. For women disposable pull-ups may be better than the other designs (except for those living in nursing homes when used at night), but they are more expensive. There is insufficient data to make any recommendations for people with faecal incontinence Absorbent Products for Moderate-Heavy Urinary and/or Faecal Incontinence in Women and Men.
Literature
Wald A. Clinical practice. Fecal incontinence in adults. N Engl J Med 2007 Apr 19;356(16):1648-55. [PubMed]