section name header

Basics

Basics

Definition

A distress response of dogs (occasionally cats) separated from the person or persons to whom they are most attached, usually their owner(s). The separation may be real (the owner is gone) or perceived (the pet is just separated from the owner). In other cases the pet may be distressed because some fear-inducing event has occurred while home alone such as thunderstorms or loud noises resulting in distress responses during other departures. The resulting distress may be evident by episodes of destruction, vocalization, and elimination. Separation anxiety is a subset of separation-related problems that may have different underlying motivations including fear, anxiety, overattachment to owner(s), and lack of appropriate stimulation or interactions.

Pathophysiology

Unknown

Systems Affected

  • Behavioral-escape attempts, howling, whining, depression, hyperactivity.
  • Cardiovascular-tachycardia.
  • Endocrine/Metabolic-increased cortisol levels, stress-induced hyperglycemia.
  • Gastrointestinal-inappetence, gastrointestinal upset.
  • Musculoskeletal-self-induced trauma resulting from escape attempts.
  • Nervous-adrenergic/noradrenergic overstimulation.
  • Respiratory-tachypnea.
  • Skin/Exocrine-acral lick dermatitis. Oral-dental damage during escape attempts.

Genetics

None known

Incidence/Prevalence

Speculated that 7–28% of companion dogs experience some degree of separation distress syndrome. May be different entities with younger dogs and senior dogs experiencing different underlying pathology.

Signalment

Species

Primarily dogs; possible in cats

Mean Age and Range

Any age, most commonly in dogs >6 months; may be another increase in prevalence in dogs >8 years.

Signs

General Comments

Destruction, vocalization, and elimination in the absence of the owner alone are not diagnostic for separation anxiety or separation distress.

Historical Findings

  • Destruction, vocalization (whining, howling, barking), and indoor elimination are commonly reported. Destruction targets windows and doors and/or owner possessions.
  • Other signs include behavioral depression, anorexia, drooling, hiding, shaking, panting, pacing, attempts to prevent owner departure, and self-trauma from lick lesions. Diarrhea and vomiting are occasionally noted.
  • Signs of strong pet-owner attachment may be present: excessive attention-seeking behaviors and following behaviors but not necessary for diagnosis.
  • Frequently owners report excessive, excited, and prolonged greeting behavior upon return.
  • Separation distress behavior(s) usually occurs regardless of the length of owner absence, often within 30 minutes of owner departure.
  • Specific triggers that are predictive of possible departure may initiate the anxiety response: getting keys, putting on outer garments, or packing the car.
  • May occur on every departure and absence or only with atypical departures or after-work, evening, or weekend departures; the reverse pattern may also be seen. May also only occur when fear-inducing stimuli are present such as noises or storms.
  • In cats, elimination problems in the owner's absence may be linked to separation-related anxiety.
  • Some animals initially show signs in the presence of acute fear or anxiety inducing events such as thunderstorms or fireworks when home alone but may recur with future departures even in the absence of stimuli.
  • Distress may also be initiated by a change in daily routine or in the household (e.g., moving).

Physical Examination Findings

  • Usually normal.
  • Injuries incurred in escape attempts or destructive activities.
  • Skin lesions from excessive licking.
  • Rare cases of dehydration from drooling or diarrhea due to stress.

Causes

Specific causes are unknown. Speculated causal factors include:

  • In owner departure and absence.
  • Lack of appropriate pet-owner interactions.
  • Prolonged contact with humans without learning to be alone.
  • Improper or incomplete early separation from the bitch (French behavior school).
  • Traumatic episodes during owner absence.
  • Change in household routine.
  • Medical issues contributing to anxiety including endocrine dysfunction, pain, sensory decline or cognitive decline.

Risk Factors

  • Suspected but not proven risk factors: adoption from humane shelters, extended time with preferred person such as during vacation or illness, boarding, lack of detachment when young.
  • Geriatric animals seem to be overrepresented.
  • Possible correlation between separation anxiety and other anxiety disorders including noise phobias.

Diagnosis

Diagnosis

Differential Diagnosis

  • Vocalization: response to outdoor influences, territorial displays, play with other pets in the home or fears.
  • Destructive behaviors: occur both when the owner is present and absent (e.g., territorial destructive displays at windows and doors; destruction due to fear-producing stimuli such as noises and thunderstorms).
  • Housesoiling: inadequate housetraining, illness, endocrine dysfunction, cognitive decline.
  • Licking due to primary dermatologic conditions.
  • Fear-based conditions that mimic separation anxiety behaviors.
  • Barrier frustration: dogs unable to be confined in crates or behind barriers but who are fine if not confined.
  • Underlying medical conditions including endocrinopathies, sensory decline, pain and cognitive dysfunction syndrome.

CBC/Biochemistry/Urinalysis

Abnormalities, if present, suggest alternate diagnosis or concurrent medical disease.

Other Laboratory Tests

Endocrine testing if indicated based on history and results of CBC and biochemistry panel

Imaging

MRI or CT if neurologic disorders are suspected

Diagnostic Procedures

  • Behavioral history
  • Video recordings of the pet when home alone to verify diagnosis.
  • Questionnaires targeting cognitive decline are advisable for geriatric dogs.
  • Skin biopsies if a dermatologic condition is suspected.
  • CSF tap if neurologic disorders are suspected.
  • Endoscopy with biopsies if gastrointestinal signs are persistent.

Treatment

Treatment

Activity

Regular, scheduled daily exercise and playtime are beneficial.

Diet

No dietary changes are necessary unless diarrhea is also present.

Client Education

General Comments

Set realistic expectations of the time course of treatment and the need for behavior modification to have successful resolution of the problem. Problem behavior may take weeks or months to resolve depending on severity and duration of the problem. Treatment components include the following.

Independence Training

  • Teach the dog to be more independent of the owner(s).
  • All attention is at owner initiation-owner begins and ends attention sessions.
  • No attention on pet demand.
  • Have the pet earn attention and food, treat or toy rewards, by performing a task such as “sit.”
  • Decrease following behavior while the owner is home. Owner must not ignore the dog, but give attention in a predictable and calm manner-requesting a sit or other calm behavior before petting, throwing a ball etc. If the dog is jumping, whining, pawing at the owner they should not receive attention for that excited behavior but the owner should wait until the dog is calm before interaction.
  • Teach the dog to calmly stay in another location away from the owner and create a safe haven for the dog to settle and relax on command. The dog must be able to be calm and relaxed when the owner is home for gradually longer times and gradually increasing separation to be calm and relaxed when they are gone.

Changing the Predictive Value of Pre-departure Cues

  • Presentation of pre-departure cues (picking up keys, walking to the door) without leaving.
  • Repeated 2–4 times daily until the dog does not respond to cues with anxious behaviors (panting, pacing, following, or increased vigilance).
  • Goal is to disassociate the cues with departures and diminish the anxious response. If the dog becomes more anxious, this step is discontinued.

Counter-Conditioning

  • Teach the dog to sit/stay near the typical exit door.
  • Owner gradually increases the distance between the dog and the exit door.
  • Owner slowly progresses toward the door, increasing the time away on each trial.
  • Eventually elements of departure, such as opening and closing the door, are added.
  • Finally, the owner steps outside the door and returns.

Classical Counter-Conditioning

  • Leaving the dog a delectable food treat or food-stuffed toy on departure.
  • Associating departure with something pleasant.

Changing Departure and Return Routine

  • Ignore the pet for 15–30 minutes prior to departure and upon return.
  • On return, attend to the dog only when it is calm and quiet.
  • May allow the dog outside to eliminate.

Graduated Planned Departures and Absences

  • Begun after dog is not responding to pre-departure cues.
  • Use short absences to teach the dog how to be home alone.
  • Departures must be short enough not to elicit a separation distress response; the pet must be calm when owners depart and calm when they return.
  • Goal-animal learns consistency of owner return and to experience departure and absence without anxiety.
  • Departures must be just like real departures (owner must do all components of departure, including leaving in the car if that is how he or she usually departs). Owner will leave a safety cue (radio or television on, ring a bell) on planned departures only (must not be used on departures where length of absence is not controlled, such as work departures).
  • Initial departures must be very short, 1–5 minutes.
  • Length of absence is slowly increased at 3–5 minute intervals if no signs of distress were evident at the shorter interval (excited greetings, barking etc.).
  • Increase in interval must be variable; intersperse short (1–3 minute) with longer (5–20 minute) departures.
  • If destruction, elimination, or vocalization occur, departure was too long. Use video recordings to assess pet anxiety.
  • If departures and absences are continued even though distress behaviors are present, the dog will get worse.
  • Audio recordings for vocalization can help monitor progress.
  • Once the pet can be left for 2–3 hours on a planned departure, it often can be left all day.
  • Cue is slowly phased out over time or can be used indefinitely.

Arrangements for the Pet During Retraining and Owner Absence

  • If possible, allow no more destructive activity.
  • Mixing up or eliminating triggering departure cues may help diminish the anxious responses.
  • Doggie daycare arrangements or pet sitters.
  • Gradual conditioning to a crate.
  • Crates must be used cautiously if at all and only in dogs that are calm when left in a crate as they may increase anxiety and result in pet injury.

Surgical Considerations

If the animal is on medication, care should be exercised prior to administering anesthesia.

Medications

Medications

Drug(s) Of Choice

Drugs for Chronic Therapy

Clomipramine

  • TCA-approved for use in the treatment of separation anxiety in dogs.
  • Approved for dogs older than 6 months of age.
  • Dosage: 2–4 mg/kg total daily dose (canine). Administered as one dose or divided twice daily; dogs may do better with dividing the dose and administering twice daily. Must be given daily, not on an “as needed” basis, and in conjunction with a behavior modification plan.
  • May take 2–4 weeks before behavioral effect is evident.
  • Side effects: vomiting, diarrhea, and lethargy.

Fluoxetine

  • SSRI-approved for use in the treatment of separation anxiety in dogs.
  • Dosage: 1–2 mg/kg PO q24h.
  • Administer in conjunction with a behavior modification plan.
  • Side effects: lethargy, decreased appetite, weight loss, and vomiting.

Drugs For Acute Anxiety At Departure

  • While waiting for an SSRI or TCA to provide anxiety relief, the use of short-term anxiolytics and pheromones is advisable in many cases.
  • Benzodiazepines: alprazolam for panic at owner departure (dog, 0.01–0.1 mg/kg) 30 minutes prior to departure. Some dogs experience paradoxical excitement with benzodiazepines, changing dosages or switching to another one may help. Polyphagia is also common with benzodiazepine administration.
  • Trazodone: A serotonin receptor antagonist and reuptake inhibitor and can be used in conjunction with a TCA or SSRI to augment calming effects. Dosage recommendation (dog) is to begin with 2–3 mg/kg PO prior to departure and titrate up gradually to effect (up to 8–10 mg/kg). Dose should be increased cautiously, especially if using with an SSRI or TCA. Side effects include: vomiting, diarrhea, sedation, ataxia, hypotension, excitement or agitation and panting and rare reports of polyphagia.
  • Adaptil: synthetic analogue of the natural appeasing pheromones of the nursing bitch that calms puppies; used to calm dogs in fearful, stressful, and anxiety situations such as separation anxiety and noise phobias; available as a plug-in diffuser for the area the dog is housed, a spray for the cage or mat, and collar.

Contraindications

  • Neither clomipramine nor fluoxetine should be used in conjunction with MAOIs such as amitraz and selegiline or within 14 days before or after an MAOI.
  • Use clomipramine with caution in patients showing cardiac conduction disturbances.
  • Caution advised using in conjunction with CNS active drugs including general anesthesia, neuroleptic, anticholinergic, and sympathomimetic drugs for dogs on either clomipramine or fluoxetine.
  • A 6-week wash-out interval should be observed following discontinuation of therapy with fluoxetine prior to administration of any drug that may interact with fluoxetine.
  • Fluoxetine should not be used in dogs with epilepsy or a history of seizures or with drugs that lower the seizure threshold (phenothiazines).
  • Practitioners are urged to read package insert for contraindications.

Precautions

  • Studies to determine effects of medication in patients less than 6 months of age have not been conducted.
  • Studies to assess the interaction of fluoxetine with TCAs have not been conducted.
  • Improperly applied behavioral modification may actually increase anxiety.
  • Crating can result in serious physical damage to the pet if it attempts to escape; it should only be recommended cautiously for those animals that are already crate-trained.
  • Animals that do not respond may have other concurrent anxieties such as noise and storm phobias.

Possible Interactions

Serotonin syndrome with MAOI and SSRI or SSRI and TCA combinations.

Alternative Drug(s)

  • TCA such as amitriptyline (dog, 1–2 mg/kg q12h) might be considered in place of clomipramine or fluoxetine.
  • Clonidine – An alpha agonist which acts as an antihypertensive agent which might be used in combination with a TCA or SSRI at a dose of 0.01–0.05 mg/kg. Begin at the lowest end of the dose range and increased cautiously.
  • Nutraceutical preparations: L-theanine (Anxitane), alpha-casosopene (Zykene) alone or in combination with l-tryptophan (Royal Canine Calm diet), or Harmonease may be useful in milder cases or adjunctively.

Follow-Up

Follow-Up

Patient Monitoring

Good client follow-up is necessary to monitor both the behavioral treatment plan and medication if prescribed. Weekly follow-up is best in the early stages to assess efficacy of the treatment plan and owner compliance with instructions. Once the dog has become more independent, habituated to pre-departure cues, and calmer on departures and returns, graduated planned departures may be implemented.

Prevention/Avoidance

Teaching animals how to be left home alone, making animals independent.

Possible Complications

  • Injuries during escape attempts.
  • Ongoing destruction and elimination disrupt the human-animal bond and result in pet relinquishment.
  • Other anxieties causing signs that mimic separation distress; if not identified and treated, the problem may worsen.

Expected Course and Prognosis

Separation anxiety often responds well to behavioral modification with or without medication. Some severe cases can be very resistant to treatment. Other concurrent behavioral disorders may make resolution more difficult. Drug therapy alone is rarely curative for most behavioral disorders. Realistically, drug therapy can be expected to decrease the anxiety associated with owner departure, but the dog still must be taught how to be left alone during owner absences.

Miscellaneous

Miscellaneous

Associated Conditions

Other anxiety conditions including noise phobias, generalized anxiety, fears, and compulsive disorders.

Age-Related Factors

Common behavior problem in senior dogs.

Synonyms

  • Hyperattachment
  • Separation anxiety

Abbreviations

  • CNS = central nervous system
  • CSF = cerebrospinal fluid
  • CT = computerized tomography
  • MAOI = monoamine oxidase inhibitor
  • MRI = magnetic resonance imaging
  • SSRI = selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor
  • TCA = tricyclic antidepressant

Author Debra F. Horwitz

Consulting Editor Gary M. Landsberg

Client Education Handout Available Online

Suggested Reading

Horwitz DF. Separation-related problem in dogs and cats. In: Horwitz DF, Mills DS, eds., BSAVA Manual of Canine and Feline Behavioural Medicine, 2nd ed. Gloucester: BSAVA, 2009, pp. 146158.

Horwitz DF, Neilson JC. Separation anxiety canine and feline. In: Blackwell's Five Minute Veterinary Consult Clinical Companion Canine and Feline Behavior. Ames, IA: Blackwell Publishing, 2007, pp. 446457.

Landsberg G, Hunthausen W, Ackerman L. Fears, phobias and anxiety disorders. In: Behavior Problems of the Dog and Cat, 3rd ed. St. Louis, MO: Saunders/Elsevier, 2013, pp. 181210.

Overall KL. Separation and noise phobias. In: Manual of Clinical Behavioral Medicine for Dogs and Cats. Elsevier, 2013, pp. 238261.