section name header

Introduction

The use of herbal medicines, dietary supplements, and other alternative products has risen sharply since passage of the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) in 1994. In contrast to prescription or nonprescription drugs, these products do not require U.S. FDA pre-approval before marketing (except for new dietary ingredients that were not in the marketplace prior to 1994). Premarketing evaluation of safety and efficacy is not mandated. However, both foreign and domestic manufacturers are required to comply with good manufacturing practices and quality control standards. Consumers often mistakenly believe that these “natural” products are free of harm and may unknowingly be at risk for illness from the products and herb-drug and herb-disease interactions, particularly with “polysupplement” use. Table II-31 lists common selected products that are available as herbal remedies or dietary supplements or that have alternative uses, along with their potential toxicities.

TABLE II-31. DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS AND ALTERNATIVE REMEDIESa
ProductSource or Active IngredientCommon or Purported Use(s)Clinical Effects and Potential Toxicity
Aconite (monkshood)Aconitine, mesaconitine, and hypaconitineRheumatism, painNausea, vomiting, paresthesia, numbness; hypotension, palpitations, ventricular tachycardia, ventricular arrhythmias.
AndrostenedioneSex steroid precursorIncrease muscle size and strengthVirilization in women, increased estrogen in men.
Anabolic steroidsMethandrostenolone, oxandrolone, testolactone, many other steroid derivativesBody buildingVirilization; feminization; cholestatic hepatitis; aggressiveness, mania, or psychosis; hypertension; acne; hyperlipidemia; immune suppression.
Antrodia cinnamomea (Taiwanofungus camphoratus)Niu Zhang ZhiAlcoholic hepatitis, cancerNone reported
Azarcon (Greta)Lead saltsHispanic folk remedy for abdominal pain, colicLead poisoning.
Bitter orangeCitrus aurantium (source of synephrine)Weight loss, athletic enhancementSynephrine: alpha-adrenergic agonist; may cause vasoconstriction, hypertension.
Black cohoshActaea racemosa and Cimicifuga racemosaMenopause symptoms, fertility,Idiosyncratic hepatitis, possibly immune related.
BufotoxinBufotenine (toad venom); “love stone”; Chan suPurported aphrodisiac, hallucinogenCardiac glycosides.
Cascara sagradaRhamnus purshianaCathartic in some diet aidsAbdominal cramps, diarrhea; fluid and electrolyte loss.
ChitosanDerived from marine exoskeletonsWeight lossDyspepsia, oily stools, shellfish hypersensitivity reaction.
Chondroitin sulfateShark or bovine cartilage or syntheticOsteoarthritisPossible anticoagulant activity.
ChromiumChromium picolinateGlucose and cholesterol lowering, athletic performance enhancementRenal insufficiency, possibly mutagenic in high doses, niacin-like flushing reaction with picolinate salt.
Cinnabar (Zhu Sha, Qing Fen)Mercuric sulfide or mercurous chlorideDifferent ethnic groups use as cosmetic, epilepsy, sores and ulcers.Mercury poisoning.
Cinnamon barkCinnamomum cassia, Cinnamomum verumDiabetes, anti-obesity, anti-inflammatorySkin irritation. At higher dose, potential to cause nephrotoxicity and hepatotoxicity.
ComfreySymphytum officinaleAnti-inflammatory, gastritis, diarrhea

Hepatic veno-occlusive disease, possible teratogen/carcinogen.

(Note: Many other plants also contain hepatotoxic pyrrolizidine alkaloids; see Table II-49.)

CreatineCreatine monohydrate, creatine monophosphateAthletic performance enhancementNausea, diarrhea, muscle cramping, rhabdomyolysis, renal dysfunction.
DanshenSalvia miltiorrhizaCardiovascular diseases, menstrual problem, wound healingAnticoagulant effect; may potentiate cardiac glycoside toxicity.
DHEADehydroepiandrosterone (an adrenal steroid)Anticancer, antiagingPossible androgenic effects.
Dong quaiAngelica sinensisMenopausal symptomsAnticoagulant effect. May potentiate anticoagulants.
EchinaceaEchinacea angustifolia Echinacea pallida Echinacea purpureaImmune stimulation, prevention of coldsAllergic reactions, possible exacerbation of autoimmune diseases.
FenugreekTrigonella foenum-graecumIncrease appetite, promote lactationHypoglycemia in large doses, anticoagulant effects possible.
FeverfewTanacetum partheniumMigraine prophylaxisAllergic reactions, antiplatelet effects.
GarlicAllium sativumHyperlipidemia, hypertensionAnticoagulant effect, gastrointestinal irritation, body odor.
GinkgoExtract of Ginkgo bilobaMemory impairment, tinnitus, peripheral vascular diseaseGastrointestinal irritation, antiplatelet effects.
GinsengPanex ginseng, Panex quinquefoliumFatigue/stress, immune stimulationDecreases glucose, increases cortisol; ginseng abuse syndrome: nervousness, insomnia, gastrointestinal distress.
GlucosamineMarine exoskeletons or syntheticOsteoarthritisPossibly decreased insulin production.
GoldensealHydrastis canadensisDyspepsia, postpartum bleeding, drug test adulterantNausea, vomiting, diarrhea, paresthesia, seizures; use during pregnancy/lactation can cause kernicterus in infants.
Grape seed extractProcyanidinsCirculatory disorders, antioxidantNone described.
Green tea extract (concentrated)Camellia sinensisMental alertness, stomach disorder, weight loss, cancerStandardized extract has been associated with hepatitis. May interact with drugs and supplements, including iron.
GuaranaCaffeineAthletic performance enhancement, appetite suppressantTachycardia, tremor, vomiting (see “Caffeine,”).
Jin bu huanL-TetrahydropalmatineChinese traditional medicineAcute CNS depression and bradycardia, chronic hepatitis.
KavaPiper methysticumAnxiety, insomniaDrowsiness; hepatitis, cirrhosis, acute liver failure; habituation; reversible skin rash.
KratomMitragyna speciosaMood enhancer, opioid substituteLow doses: euphoria, mild stimulant; high doses: dizziness, dysphoria, somnolence; may cause seizures and coma.
LicoriceGlycyrrhiza glabraHeartburn, eczema (topical).High and prolonged dose may lead to sodium and water retention. Hypokalemia.
Ma huangEphedrine (various Ephedra spp)Stimulant, athletic performance enhancement, appetite suppressantInsomnia; hypertension, tachycardia, cardiac dysrhythmias, stroke; psychosis, seizures.
MelatoninPineal glandCircadian rhythm sleep disordersDrowsiness, headache, transient depressive symptoms.
Milk thistleSilybum marianumToxic hepatitis and other liver diseasesMild Gl distress, possible allergic reaction.
NattokinaseEnzyme extracted from natto, a Japanese fermented soybean productAnticoagulant, fibrinolytic; also promoted for Alzheimer diseaseBleeding; additive anticoagulant effect with other drugs.
PhenibutBeta-phenyl-GABAAnxiety, insomniaGABA-B agonist: lethargy, stupor, respiratory depression, mydriasis, hypothermia; withdrawal syndrome after prolonged use.
Realgar (Xiong Huang, Ci Huang)Arsenic sulfide, arsenic trisulfideUsed for religious purpose, pigments and dyes. Medicinal use as antibioticArsenic poisoning.
SAMeS-Adenosyl-L methionineDepressionMild gastrointestinal distress, mania (rare).
Saw palmettoSerenoa repensBenign prostatic hypertrophyAntiandrogenic, headache.
SennaCassia angustifolia, Cassia acutifoliaWeight loss, laxativeWatery diarrhea, abdominal cramps, fluid and electrolyte loss.
Shark cartilagePacific Ocean shark Squalus acanthiasCancer, arthritisBad taste, hepatitis, hypercalcemia, hyperglycemia.
SpirulinaSome blue-green algaeBody buildingNiacin-like flushing reaction.
St. John wortHypericum perforatumDepressionPossible mild MAO inhibition, photosensitivity, P-glycoprotein and P450 enzyme induction.
Tea tree oilMelaleuca alternifoliaLice, scabies, ringworm, vaginitis, acneSedation and ataxia when taken orally; contact dermatitis, local skin irritation.
L-TryptophanEssential amino acidInsomnia, depressionEosinophilia-myalgia syndrome due to contaminants in tryptophan reported in 1989; similar contaminants found in 5-hydroxytryptophan and melatonin.
Valerian rootValeriana officinalis, Valeriana edulisInsomniaSedation, vomiting.
VanadiumVanadyl sulfateBody buildingGreenish discoloration of tongue, intestinal cramps, diarrhea, renal dysfunction.
XanthiumXanthium sibiricumHyperglycemia, hypertension, pain, anticoagulant, rhinitisHeadache, dizziness, nausea, vomiting, bradycardia, tachycardia; hepatic toxins leading to hepatic failure.
YohimbineCorynanthe yohimbeSexual dysfunctionHallucinations, tachycardia, tremor, hypertension, irritability, gastrointestinal irritation.
ZincZinc gluconate lozengesFlu/cold symptomsNausea, mouth/throat irritation, anosmia.

aMost of these products are legally considered food supplements and therefore are not as tightly regulated by the FDA as pharmaceuticals (Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act [DSHEA] of 1994). Toxicity may be related to the active ingredient(s) or to impurities, contaminants, or adulterants in the product. See also “Caffeine”, “Camphor and Other Essential Oils” (p 172), “Salicylates”, and “Vitamins”.

1.FDA Office of Food Safety and Nutrition: Consumer alerts and health professional advisories about safety concerns related to botanical products and other dietary supplements. https://www.fda.gov/food/recalls-outbreaks-emergencies/alerts-advisories-safety-information

2.The Poisonous Plant database provides access to references in the scientific literature (primarily print literature through about 2007) describing studies and reports of the toxic properties and effects of plants and plant parts. https://www.fda.gov/food/science-research-food/fda-poisonous-plant-database

3.National Institutes of Health Dietary Supplement Label Database. https://dsld.od.nih.gov/dsld/

4.National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK) LiverTox® Database. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK547852/

Mechanism of Toxicity

  1. Adulterants. A number of poisonings related to herbal preparations have been caused by heavy metals such as cadmium, lead, arsenic, and mercury, or pharmaceuticals such as sildenafil, fluoxetine, sibutramine, phenolphthalein, dapoxetine, and designer steroids. Many of these products are marketed for sexual enhancement, weight loss, muscle building, or treatment of diabetes. As a general rule, if the product results in an immediate effect, it may mean that the product contains pharmaceutical rather than natural herbal ingredients.
  2. Misidentification. Some herbs are intrinsically toxic, and poisoning may occur as a result of misidentification or mislabeling of plant materials, as occurred with a Belgian slimming formulation contaminated with the herb Stephania fangchi containing the nephrotoxin aristolochic acid.
  3. Improper or nontraditional processing. Many herbs must be processed to remove the toxins before they are consumed. One example is aconite root, which contains cardiotoxic and neurotoxic alkaloids. Green tea extract (concentrated through processing, different from regular green tea) has been linked to a number of hepatitis cases and should not be taken on an empty stomach.
  4. Herb-drug interactions. Dietary supplements may potentiate or diminish the effects of drugs with a narrow therapeutic index. Ginseng (Panax ginseng), Salvia miltiorrhiza (Danshen), nattokinase, and Ginkgo biloba appear to have anticoagulant effects and should not be used concomitantly with warfarin, aspirin, or other anticoagulant or antiplatelet therapies. St. John's wort has been shown to have several clinically significant pharmacokinetic interactions with substrates for p-glycoprotein and the cytochrome P450 system. Green tea interacts with a number of drugs including statins, nadolol, sildenafil, tacrolimus, and warfarin via inhibition of metabolism and absorption.
  5. Allergic reactions. Raw botanical herbs may cause allergic reactions. Many herbs are treated with sulfur as a preservative and should be used with caution in consumers who have known sulfur allergy.
  6. Pesticides are commonly used on botanical products, and consumers may be unknowingly exposed to these chemicals resulting in acute or chronic poisoning.

Clinical Presentation

Depends on the toxic constituent of the herbal product and may be acute in onset (eg, with the cardiac-stimulant effects of ephedra or guarana) or delayed (as with Chinese herbal nephropathy caused by Aristolochia). Allergic reactions to botanical products may manifest with skin rash (including urticaria), bronchospasm, and even anaphylaxis.

Diagnosis

Is based on a history of use of alternative products and exclusion of other medical/toxicologic causes. Identification of an unknown herb may be facilitated by consulting with a local Chinese herbalist, acupuncturist, or naturopathic practitioner. In some cases, chemical analysis of the product may confirm the presence of the suspected causative constituent or contaminant.

  1. Specific levels. Quantitative levels are not available for most alternative medicine toxins. Ephedrine can be measured in the blood and urine of people taking Ma huang. Some immunoassays for amphetamines are sensitive to ephedrine.
  2. Laboratory studies. Serum electrolytes including glucose, BUN, creatinine, liver aminotransferases, and prothrombin time are useful in cases of suspected organ toxicity resulting from alternative therapies. Heavy metals screening is recommended if consistent with poisoning.

Treatment

  1. Emergency and supportive measures. Toxic effects of herbal medicines should be managed with the same approach taken with other ingestions.
    1. Replace fluid losses caused by diarrhea or vomiting with IV crystalloid fluids.
    2. Treat hypertension, tachycardia, and arrhythmias if they occur.
    3. Treat anxiety, agitation, or seizures caused by stimulant herbs with IV benzodiazepines.
    4. Maintain an open airway and assist ventilation if necessary in cases of CNS depression or coma related to sedative herb use.
  2. Specific drugs and antidotes. There are no specific antidotes for toxicity related to herbal and alternative products.
  3. Decontamination. Administer activated charcoal orally if conditions are appropriate (see Table I-37). Gastric lavage is not necessary after small-to-moderate ingestions if activated charcoal can be given promptly.
  4. Enhanced elimination. The effectiveness of these procedures in removing herbal and alternative medicine toxins has not been studied.