| PRK | LASEK | Epi-LASIK | LASIK | SMILE |
---|
Epithelial flap or method of stromal exposure | No flap. Epithelium removed by blade, spatula, brush, excimer laser, or dilute absolute alcohol. | Epithelial flap created by 20% absolute alcohol concentrated on epithelium by marker well. | Epithelial flap created by a blunt blade epi-keratome. Epithelial flap may be replaced (epi-on) or discarded (epi-off). | Epithelial and stromal flap created by sharp microkeratome or femtosecond laser. | No flap. Thin disc of stroma created by femtosecond laser and then mechanically extracted through small incision. |
Depth of exposure | Bowman membrane | Bowman membrane | Bowman membrane | Anterior stroma (sub-Bowman keratomileusis provides more superficial stromal exposure) | Anterior stroma |
Typical refractive limitations | Spherical range: −8.0D to +3.0D, cylinder range up to 3.0D | Spherical range: −8.0D to +3.0D, cylinder range up to 3.0D | Spherical range: −8.0D to +3.0D, cylinder range up to 3.0D | Spherical range: −10.0D to +3.0D, cylinder range up to 3.0D | Spherical range: −10.0D to −1.0D, cylinder range up to 3.0D |
Advantages | Useful in thin corneas, epithelial pathology. No stromal flap healing issues. | Useful in thin corneas, epithelial pathology. No stromal flap healing issues. | Useful in thin corneas, epithelial pathology. No stromal flap healing issues. | Minimal pain, rapid visual recovery, minimal stromal haze. | Minimal pain, rapid visual recovery. No flap complications. Possibly less dry eye than LASIK. |
Disadvantages | Postoperative pain, slower visual recovery, higher risk of subepithelial haze. | Postoperative pain, slower visual recovery, higher risk of subepithelial haze. | Postoperative pain, slower visual recovery, higher risk of subepithelial haze. Not ideal with significant glaucoma or anterior corneal scarring. | Not ideal for thin corneas, epithelial dystrophies, severe dry eyes, significant glaucoma. Presence of flap with possible complications (see text). | Currently only for myopia or myopic astigmatism in the US. Not ideal for thin corneas or in corneas with epithelial pathology. Removal of stromal lenticule can be technically difficult. SMILE enhancements complex; reoperations often done with PRK. |