After reading this chapter, you should be able to:
Relevant Nursing Education Standards to the Chapter Content
AACN Essentials Relevant Standard Domains and Concepts:Knowledge for Nursing Practice, Professionals, Person-Centered Care, Quality and Safety, Interprofessional Partnerships, Systems-Based Care, Informatics and Healthcare Technologies, Professionalism Concepts:Clinical judgment, communication, compassionate care, diversity/equity/inclusion. Ethics, evidence-based practice, health policy, social determinants of health (AACN, 2021)
NLN Values Related to Standards:Culture of caring, diversity and inclusion, excellence, and integrity (NLN, 2021)
Chapter Outline
Healthcare delivery is a complex process and system, which includes many types of healthcare provider organizations, such as acute care organizations (hospitals), ambulatory care centers (clinics), private provider offices, public/community health facilities and services, home healthcare agencies, hospice agencies, extended care facilities, and so on. This chapter focuses on the most common type of healthcare organization (HCO): the acute care hospital. This does not mean that other types of HCOs, such as in public/community health, are not important; however, nursing students typically spend more of their clinical time in hospitals. Many of the organizational elements of a hospital are similar to those of other HCOs but may vary depending on the organization and purpose. The content in this chapter explores current issues related to hospitals and hospital organization and function and the hospital provider team, and introduces content about healthcare financial issues and the nursing organization and functions within the hospital.
Many factors affect hospitals, leading them to change their services, collaborate with others in their communities, realign their organization with other organizations, hospital closures due to financial issues, meet quality improvement requirements, and so forth. Examples of factors that influence hospitals today include the following:
Examples of key influences on health care are highlighted in Figure 8-1. Exhibit 8-1 identifies examples of organizations that influence healthcare delivery.
Figure 8-1 Influences on healthcare delivery.
A complex Venn diagram with overlapping circles depicts Economics, Patient population, Government regulations, Research, Healthcare professional education, Healthcare provider, Healthcare needs, and Healthcare policies. The overlapping regions highlight the interconnectedness of these factors.
Exhibit 8-1 Examples of Organizations Important to the Healthcare Delivery System |
---|
|
Corporatization of Health Care: How Did We Get Here?
Using the term corporatization or business when referring to a hospital may seem strange; however, health care is a business-a very large, complex business. It provides services to most of the population at some time during a person's life, from birth to death. Hospitals have a very large employee pool, with nurses representing the largest percentage. Within a community, hospitals provide jobs for many people-both professionals and nonprofessionals; thus, they often represent one of the largest employment sectors. Within a community, HCOs may own or lease a large amount of property, purchase a large number of supplies and equipment, and pay taxes-all activities that bring income into a community. Typically, healthcare leaders hold significant positions in the business sector and the community. Healthcare consumes the largest amount of federal and state dollars through healthcare reimbursement programs, such as Medicare and Medicaid.
It is not uncommon to refer to hospitals as for-profit or not-for-profit. These terms can be confusing. The first critical point is that every hospital needs to make a profit, which means HCOs need to have money left over after expenses are paid. The distinguishing characteristic between for-profit and not-for-profit organizations is what the organization does with its profit. The assumption made by most people is all hospitals are not-for-profit organizations, but this is not correct. Many HCOs are for-profit corporations. Some of their profit must go to their stockholders/shareholders or to their owners. However, even not-for-profit organizations must also cover their operation costs and reinvest money in the hospital for maintenance, expand space and renovate, develop new services, purchase equipment and supplies, hire new staff, and so on. Not-for-profit organizations do not have stockholders/shareholders, but they still need to make a profit for the same reason that for-profit organizations need a profit: to cover expenses.
Knowing whether the hospital you work for is a for-profit or not-for-profit organization can help you understand why and how decisions are made. For example, if a hospital is burdened with a high number of nonpaying patients, the hospital may eventually spend more than it is making and thus be in the red when its debt increases. When this happens, the hospital may cut staff, limit new equipment purchases, control the use of supplies, fail to maintain equipment effectively, neglect facility maintenance needs and renovation, attempt to reconfigure services to attract paying patients, decrease staff education, and make other changes to improve the hospital's financial condition but this may have a negative impact on patients and on the staff. All HCOs need to be concerned with cost containment, but when the financial situation is weak, the organization needs to expand cost containment to manage its finances. A for-profit HCO must always have funds to pay stockholders or owners, and this consideration may have an impact on the availability of money for other purposes that affect nurses and nursing staffing, such as the issues mentioned here. Both for-profit and not-for-profit HCOs can experience financial difficulties.
Stop and Consider 1 |
---|
Healthcare delivery is a business. |
The Healthcare Organization
Hospitals represent the largest type of HCO. Other types of HCOs are identified in Exhibit 8-2. Descriptions of an HCO should include information about the organization's structure, processes, staff, and organizational culture. Although most of the work done by registered nurses (RNs) is done in hospitals, many also work in other types of HCOs, with the percentage of RNs working in hospitals decreasing over recent years. Nurses work in all of the healthcare settings identified in Exhibit 8-2. Data from 2022 indicated that 30.85% of RNs worked in general medical and surgical hospitals, 14.87% in outpatient care settings, 11.31% in home healthcare services, 9.28% in nursing care facilities, and 7.50% in physician offices, representing small changes compared to 2019 (DOL, BLS, 2022).
Exhibit 8-2 Types of Healthcare Organizations |
---|
|
Hospitals can vary in their organizational structure, but there are some standard types of organizations. In the past, it was more common for hospitals to operate as single organizations. Now, more hospitals have formed complex organizations consisting of multiple hospitals, which may be spread across a state or even a national system with hospitals in multiple states. In some cases, these systems also include other healthcare entities, such as home healthcare agencies, rehabilitation centers, long-term care facilities, and freestanding ambulatory care centers to support a continuum of care between acute care and public and community health services. Most of the reasons for this change in hospital organization structure to include different services are related to financial issues and the survival of the organization-to keep patients in the system and increase services. Some communities have experienced multiple changes in their local hospitals, with hospitals merging with other hospitals or others trying to go it alone. The critical message is that hospitals are changing their overall organization, and it is not clear what the future holds for healthcare access in some communities.
Small hospitals with 100 or fewer beds and hospitals in rural areas are particularly vulnerable. They often have difficulty getting enough admissions and, therefore, often lose money. In addition, even though they may be small, they must keep costly equipment current by purchasing new equipment and maintaining their equipment, physical facilities, and an acceptable staffing level.
There are also community crises, public health emergencies, and disasters that require more services that may be costly, such as the services required for COVID-19 patients increasing the need for ventilators and other complex and protective equipment. If the community is struggling economically, this has an impact on patients paying for services with or without health insurance. The American Hospital Association (AHA) noted that there was a critical problem with hospital finances with more hospitals operating in the red due to COVID care due to the increased need for complex, staff intensive care and also the need to reduce services for non-COVID patients in order to provide these critical services for COVID (AHA, 2020; Stuart, 2020). Hospitals also need to maintain a certain level of staff, including staff with certain expertise and specialists (physicians, nurses, and others). This is not a business that can easily flex staff numbers and use a lot of temporary staff, and it takes time to orient new and temporary staff. These vulnerable hospitals, such as rural hospitals, may have problems recruiting RNs for their workforces because many RNs prefer to work in urban centers and in large, up-to-date hospitals, and similar problems occur with physicians. Schools of nursing in states with large rural areas partner with rural hospitals to improve student enrollment from these areas and, they hope, increase the RN pool in the workforce for these geographic regions. Such partnerships provide courses and clinical experiences in rural healthcare settings and may use virtual methods to facilitate access to nursing programs, making it easier for students and reducing student travel time to campus.
Healthcare spending is high, and it is important that the healthcare delivery system considers expenses and how money is used in the system. For example, in 2022, clinical waste represented 5.4-15.7% of national health spending. Clinical waste is caused by failures of care delivery, failures of care coordination, and overtreatment (Health Affairs, 2022). The issue of waste was identified as a major concern in the 2013 IOM report on U.S. health care and is now monitored, as seen in the 2022 data. The report indicated that there was a need to focus on the best care at a lower cost, not a higher cost (IOM, 2013). The report Best Care at Lower Cost: The Path to Continuously Learning Health Care in America described the system in this way: Health care in America presents a fundamental paradox. The past 50 years have seen an explosion in biomedical knowledge, dramatic innovation in therapies and surgical procedures, and management of conditions that previously were fatal, with ever more exciting clinical capabilities on the horizon. Yet, American health care is falling short on basic dimensions of quality, outcomes, costs, and equity (IOM, 2013, p. 1). Organizations involved in healthcare quality, such as the Institute for Health Improvement (IHI), also noted that there is a need to reduce waste and cost in the U.S. healthcare system. Waste is more than just ordering too many supplies. It can include over-diagnosis, unnecessary diagnostics, and unnecessary surgery. For example, to avoid waste there's been a big shift away from doing invasive diagnostic tests for things like radiology studies for mild lower back pain or pap smears every year for healthy younger women. These are tests that turn up a lot of false positives and expose patients to unnecessary risks. They also cost a lot of money and cause worry for patients without leading to improved outcomes resources (IHI, 2019). Waste also relates to errors when time and supplies may be wasted. HCOs need to identify and address clinical waste, including through state-level data collection and education efforts. Research on medical error also highlights a range of interventions with the potential to reduce waste and improve quality, including physician resident handoff programs, the use of surgical checklists, and other interventions to build safety cultures in hospitals. Identification and reduction of medical waste must be a key component of any broad strategy to moderate health care spending growth and improve patient outcomes (Health Affairs, 2022). There are many strategies that can be used to decrease waste and improve care, as illustrated by some of these methods. Reducing waste also means that monies that might have been lost in waste may be needed for other purposes in healthcare delivery, supporting effective and efficient services (Bogan, 2019).
In summary, compared to other countries, the United States is paying more for less, resulting in poorer healthcare outcomes than are found in other industrialized nations. The complex U.S. healthcare delivery system must better manage costs while simultaneously ensuring quality, evidence-based care. Trying to achieve this balance leads to more changes in the healthcare delivery system and impacts nursing. Nurses need to be involved in improving and balancing the need for financial support and quality care.
Structure and Process
One way to describe a hospital is to consider its structure and process. A hospital's structure is based on an organization's configuration, and the best source for a view of a hospital's structure is its organizational chart. Figure 8-2 provides an example of a hospital organizational chart, which displays a vertical view of hospital components. The chart identifies the staff reporting path, or rather, who is a staff member's manager or supervisor, not by name but by position title. Organizations that focus on this type of structure tend to be more bureaucratic and highly centralized, with key persons in the organization making decisions. Bureaucratic organizations typically have the following characteristics:
Figure 8-2 Example of a hospital organizational chart.
A hierarchical organizational chart depicts the structure of a hospital.
At the top is the Board of Directors, followed by the President and Chief Executive Officer, C E O. Below the C E O is the Senior Vice President and Chief Operating Officer, C O O. Reporting to the C O O are several Vice Presidents: Chief Information Officer, C I O, Quality and Patient Safety, Human Resources, Medical Affairs, Professional Practice and Chief Nursing Officer, C N O, and Chief Financial Officer, C F O.
Hospitals typically have hierarchical management levels. The top level consists of the board of trustees or board of directors. The board often includes members of the community and community leaders who are not directly involved in health care. The goal is to have a broad range of input from different stakeholders to assist in developing the overall direction of the hospital and ensure that the goals of the organization and the community are met. The board hires the hospital's chief executive officer (CEO-sometimes called the organization's president), and this person reports to the board. The CEO then hires the other major leaders for the hospital, such as the chief financial officer (CFO) and the nursing leader, who may be called the chief nursing executive (CNE), the chief nursing officer (CNO), or in some cases, the vice president for nursing or patient services. The last title reflects the person's oversight of nursing but may also include other disciplines or ancillary services, such as occupational therapy, physical therapy, or nutrition. Often, the board approves management/leadership hires recommended by the CEO. Because the board has ultimate responsibility for the budget, it has significant influence over matters that impact nurses, such as staffing and other resources important to nursing.
Although bureaucratic organizations are less common today, many hospitals still use this approach, emphasizing a vertical structure that includes these elements, but it is less rigid than the structure of past formal bureaucratic organizations. Line authority, or chain of command, is very important in that each staff member needs to know to whom to report, and it is expected that this order will be followed. A bureaucratic organization may not expect or want much staff input regarding decisions, but today, this model is less common. HCO administrations are now encouraging more staff commitment and, thus, engagement in the organization-greater emphasis on teams and interprofessional collaboration. Another element of organizational structure is the span of control, or the number of staff managed by each supervisor or manager. The more staff a manager supervises, the more complex that supervision becomes.
A horizontal structure is decentralized, with emphasis placed on departments or divisions and decision-making occurring closer to where work is done. Departments or divisions focus on special functions, such as those related to nursing, laboratory, pharmacy, dietary/patient, and medical services. This is referred to as departmentalization. Later in this chapter, examples of common hospital departments or services are discussed.
The matrix organization structure is newer and less clear than the traditional bureaucratic organization that is centered on departments. In a matrix organization, staff might be part of a functional department, such as nursing services, but if the nurse works in surgery, the nurse may also be considered a staff member in the surgical services/department. This type of organization is considered flatter because decisions do not flow clearly from the top down but focus more on the service or department, though there still must be consideration of the overall organization structure and functions.
Process, the other dimension of organizations, focuses on how the organization functions. How would a staff member gain an understanding of a hospital's process? The hospital's vision, mission statement, and goals are a good place to begin to find out what is important to the organization and how the hospital describes itself and its functions. Other sources of information relevant to the process include policies and procedures, communication systems and expectations, decision-making processes, delegation processes, implementation of coordination (teams), informatics, and evaluation methods (quality improvement [QI]). The key question is: How does the work get done?
Classification of Hospitals
Hospitals can be classified using a variety of descriptors. The following are some of these descriptors:
Typical Departments in a Hospital
As was discussed in relation to the structure of organizations, hospitals have departments, divisions, and/or services. This structure has existed for a long time. Students need to be familiar with these departments because nurses interact with most of them at some point in their practice, and they need to know how to coordinate care by using services from a variety of departments and collaborating with interprofessional staff. What are some of the departments found in an acute care hospital? Titles may vary from hospital to hospital, but the functions described here are typical and part of daily hospital operations.
Other departments focus on specific health needs, such as pharmacy, respiratory therapy, clinical laboratory, infusion therapy, occupational therapy, radiology, and Physical therapy. Nurses are involved in all these services. Hospitals are typically organized around clinical areas (units, services, and, in some cases, departments), such as medicine, surgery, intensive care (medical intensive care unit [MICU], surgical intensive care unit [SICU], cardiac care unit [CCU], and neonatal intensive care unit [NICU]), postanesthesia unit (PACU), labor and delivery (L&D), postpartum, nursery, gynecology, pediatrics, emergency department (ED), urgent care, psychiatric or behavioral/mental health, ambulatory care, ambulatory care surgery, and dialysis. Clinical areas may also focus on a specialty, such as medical units for the postcardiac care unit, which may be referred to as step-down units, oncology units, or other internal medicine subspecialties; surgical units might focus on orthopedics, urology, and so on.
Patient Flow
The right care in the right place and at the right time can sometimes be a challenge both for patients and for healthcare providers and HCOs (Rutherford, 2020). Healthcare systems are complex and difficult to manage. Over the years, there has been increased concern about patient flow-patients not moving from one area of care to another when they need to be moved or may not be in the best healthcare service area for their care needs. The COVID-19 pandemic exacerbated this long-term problem, increasing the number of patients waiting for services in emergency departments and even in ambulances or having no contact with needed services (Rutherford, 2020). Mental health services have had patient flow problems with barriers to providing effective and efficient ambulatory care, inpatient care, long-term care, and care in the home. Hospital-wide patient flow needs to be addressed, as it impacts nurses and their practice. Services are interdependent but are not always aware of each other and what needs to be done to increase effective patient flow. This impacts the system's communication, coordination, staffing, staff stress, patient transportation, supplies and pharmaceutical needs, workload, patient reimbursement, admissions and discharges, and budget. Understanding the problem is the first step-what interferes with patient flow? Staff need to develop methods to resolve the problems, and this requires staff communication and collaboration. Patients and families should be asked about these issues-they may have suggestions that would improve patient flow.
Stop and Consider 2 |
---|
Organizational structure and process affect healthcare organizations. |
Healthcare Providers: Who Is on the Team?
The hospital healthcare team providing care is composed of a variety of healthcare providers, both professional and nonprofessional. All are important in the care process. In addition, many other staff are critical to the overall operation of a hospital, such as staff associated with office support, dietary, housekeeping, facilities management and maintenance, patient transportation, medical records, communications (HIT), equipment maintenance and repair, security, and many others. For our purposes in this text, the focus is on staff that provide care, either direct or indirect patient care. A staff member who provides direct care, such as a nurse, is in contact with the patient, referred to as a direct care provider. An indirect care provider might be someone who works in the lab to complete a lab test but may never actually see the patient; however, the work done in the lab is very important to patient care.
The group of staff who provide care to a patient is referred to as a team. They have a common purpose: providing patient care. Interprofessional teamwork is one of the recommended competencies for all healthcare professionals and is discussed in other chapters. Nurses work together with other nursing staff (licensed vocational nurses [LVNs] or licensed practical nurses [LPNs] and nursing/patient care assistants) to provide care. Today, there is also greater emphasis on the need for interprofessional teams in which nurses collaborate and coordinate with members of multiple disciplines, such as physicians, pharmacists, physical therapists, social workers, and many other members.
The following are examples of some of the major team members and their functions. Not all patients require services from all these healthcare professionals; PCC services are based on individual patient needs.
Medical care in acute care has been examined over the last few years, identifying several problem areas that have led to changes in some hospitals. Two of the newest members of the healthcare team are the hospitalist and the intensivist. The hospitalist position is usually filled by a doctor of medicine (MD), although APRNs may hold this position in some hospitals (Carlson, 2020). The hospitalist is a generalist who coordinates the patient's care, serving as the primary provider while the patient is in the hospital. In this case, the patient's primary care provider outside the hospital is not involved in the patient's inpatient care, and the patient returns to that provider in the community after discharge. This reduces the time that the primary care provider (internist, family practitioner, pediatrician) needs to devote to inpatient care. Thus, the primary care provider (PCP) has more time to focus on the patient's outpatient needs. In addition, the hospitalist is more current with acute care and the treatment required. The intensivist is similar to the hospitalist, but because this MD focuses on patient care in intensive care, this is more specialized patient care and requires physicians who are up to date on critical information and intensive care procedures. The hospitalist and intensivist positions were developed to increase coordination and continuity of care in the hospital. Both providers are paid hospital employees. A major disadvantage of this medical care model is that the patient has no relationship with the hospitalist or the intensivist prior to hospitalization and will not have any contact after hospitalization, which may not be acceptable to some patients. If APRNs are in this role, this, too, may not be acceptable to some patients. Patient choice is always an important factor to consider as this has a direct impact on patient satisfaction and patient engagement in the care process and on outcomes.
Stop and Consider 3 |
---|
Nurses need to understand the roles of multiple healthcare providers. |
Healthcare Financial Issues
Healthcare financial issues can be viewed from three perspectives. The first perspective is the macro view, or the status of healthcare finances viewed from a national or a state perspective. The second is the micro view, which focuses on a specific HCO and its budget. A third perspective is reimbursement for individual healthcare organization services.
The Nation's Health Care: Financial Status (Macro View)
The macro view is important because it encompasses the major financial support for the U.S. healthcare system. The United States spends a lot of money on health care, yet not everyone is covered by healthcare insurance. As is true for the reporting of most government data, national health expenditures (NHE) data are behind the current year. The data for 2018 indicated the following (HHS, CMS, 2021):
To plan for future healthcare needs, the government also projects NHE, as noted in the following for 2019-2028:
It is important to note that this projection does not fully consider the financial impact of COVID-19 on healthcare expenditures. It is recognized that the COVID-19 pandemic has had a major impact on individuals and their ability to cover healthcare costs, healthcare providers (individuals and healthcare organizations, health insurance), and government budgets (local, state, federal)-short-term and long-term impact.
Reimbursement issues impact the status of health care and coverage of these expenses. Figure 8-3 describes the nation's healthcare dollar, describing CMS reimbursement as it is the major payer at the federal level-how much Medicare and Medicaid spent on different categories of services and Figure 8-4 describes CMS payments for services. These expenditures are changing, and they are increasing.
Figure 8-3 The nation's health dollar, calendar year 2021, where it went.
Two pie charts depict the distribution of the nation's health spending in 2022.
The left pie chart depicts overall spending: Hospital Care: 30 percent. Physician and Clinical Services: 20 percent. Prescription Drugs: 9 percent. Government Administration and Net cost of Health Insurance: 7 percent. Other Health Residential and Personal Care, superscript 2: 6 percent. Investment, superscript 1: 5 percent, Public Health Activities: 5 percent. Nursing Care Facilities and Continuing Care Retirement Communities: 4 percent. Other: 14 percent. The right pie chart breaks down Dental Services: 4 percent. Other: Home Health Care: 3 percent. Other Professional Services: 3 percent. Other Non-Durable Medical Products: 3 percent. Durable Medical Equipment: 2 percent. Text for superscript 1 reads, Includes non-commercial research and structures and equipment. Includes expenditures for residential care facilities, ambulance providers, medical care delivered in non-traditional settings, such as community centers, senior citizens centers, schools, and military field stations, and expenditures for Home and Community Waiver programs under Medicaid. Sum of pieces may not equal 100 percent due to rounding. Source: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Office of the Actuary, National Health Statistics Group.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Office of the Actuary, National Health Statistics Group (NHS). (2021). https://www.cms.gov/files/document/nations-health-dollar-where-it-came-where-it-went.pdf
Figure 8-4 Medicare benefit payments by type of service.
Two pie charts illustrate the sources of the 4.5 trillion dollars for the health sector for the calendar year 2022.
The left pie chart depicts the overall distribution: Health Insurance: 72 percent. Out of Pocket, superscript 2: 11 percent. Other Third Party Payers and Programs, superscript 1: 8 percent. Investment: 5 percent. Government Public Health Activities: 5 percent. The right pie chart breaks down Health Insurance: Private Health Insurance is 29 percent, Medicare 21 percent, Medicaid, Federal, 13 percent, Medicaid, State and Local, 5 percent, and V A, D O D, and CHIP 4 percent. Text for superscript 1 reads, Includes worksite health care, other private revenues, Indian Health Service, workers' compensation, general assistance, maternal and child health, vocational rehabilitation, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, school health, and other federal and state and local programs. Superscript 2 reads, includes co-payments, deductibles, and any amounts not covered by health insurance. Note: Sum of pieces may not equal 100 percent due to rounding. Source: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, Office of the Actuary, National Health Statistics Group.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Office of the Actuary, National Health Statistics Group (NHS). (2021). https://www.cms.gov/files/document/nations-health-dollar-where-it-came-where-it-went.pdf
The Individual Healthcare Organization and Its Financial Needs (Micro View)
The hospital budget is used by hospitals to manage their financial issues-to plan, monitor expenses and revenue, and then adjust to ensure financial stability. The budget is prepared for a specific period, usually a year. In addition, a longer-term strategic plan, covering several years is prepared, although this plan must be adjusted over time because of changes in the HCO's financial status and other factors that affect the HCO and its services. The budget describes expected expenses, such as staff salaries and benefits, equipment, supplies, utilities, pharmaceutical needs, facility maintenance, dietary needs, administrative services, clinical care, HIT, QI, staff education, legal fees, the HCO's insurance coverage, parking and security, and so on, and includes any major expenses outside of operating expenses, such as expansion or renovation. This budget also includes projected revenue or money coming into the organization.
It is very important for nursing management to participate in the budget process because the budget has a major impact on nurses and nursing care. Reimbursement and other aspects of healthcare finance affect nursing care and relate to the following questions:
All of these are critical questions and of interest to nursing staff. Nursing leaders in an organization should be actively involved in cost-containment decisions because these decisions affect answers to these questions. Nurses should also work collaboratively with interprofessional leaders and staff recognizing that financial decisions are not limited to one specific profession or service. This, however, requires that nurses understand and consider financial issues objectively. More content on health economics is needed in nursing education programs to develop competencies not only for graduate students but also for prelicensure students (Platt et al., 2015). The AACN Essentials include recognition of the need for baccalaureate degree programs to incorporate knowledge of financial and payment models offering content on reimbursement and healthcare costs in the domain focused on systems-based practice (AACN, 2021). Nurse managers and administrators have the most responsibility for financial decisions; however, for staff nurses to actively engage and be effective in the organization, they, too, need to have some understanding of this area and provide input when needed. Nurses are not usually directly involved in the development of budgets unless they are in a management position; however, it is important for nurses to understand what a budget is and why it is important. Nurse managers need to ask their nursing staff for input when unit budgets are developed and then share budget outcomes with staff, asking for suggestions when there is need to resolve budget issues. The nursing department administrator should consult with department nurse managers as budgets are developed and monitored.
The hospital board of directors approves the final HCO budget, which combines budgets from the HCO units, departments, and other components. After a budget is approved and implemented, it is important that budgetary data are monitored on a regular basis, and this information should be shared with the organization's managers throughout the year. This monitoring is done to better ensure that budget goals are met and facilitate early recognition of budget issues that may require adjustment in the budget and in the workplace.
Reimbursement: Who Pays for Health Care?
Reimbursement is a critical, complex topic in health care. It represents the third perspective on healthcare financial issues. Nursing students may wonder why this topic is relevant to them or even to nurses in general. Basically, reimbursement pays the patient's bill for services provided, and this payment, in turn, covers the costs of care, such as staff salaries and benefits, drugs, medical supplies, physician fees, facility maintenance and upgrades, equipment, general supplies, and much more. These monies then provide healthcare providers with funds to pay their own bills and cover their services. So, for example, reimbursement dollars eventually become the dollars that pay staff salaries and benefits in hospitals, clinics, physician practices, home healthcare agencies, and so on.
Hospitals that do not have enough income to pay their bills are said to be operating in the red, and this is not a good position for a hospital. Many hospitals experience this problem, but how far in the red can make the difference between modernizing or filling staff positions or not doing so-even if the hospital stays open for business. Some hospitals in this country have closed, and the United States also experienced closings because of COVID-19. This may have been due to a combination of long-term financial weakness and then the pandemic exacerbated the financial problems (Stuart, 2020). Particularly hard hit are hospitals in rural areas and small hospitals that are not able to compete for patients. Their closing may have a major impact on access to care in some communities resulting in some patients not having access to a local hospital for needed services or even for emergency services. In some communities where local small hospitals may have limited services, people may have to travel long distances for services such as obstetric care or specialized care for children (pediatrics, neonatal care for newborns), mental health services, oncology (diagnosis and treatment), complex surgical procedures, and other specialized services.
The United States is experiencing a crisis in its safety net hospitals. The government defines safety net hospitals as hospitals that provide a significant amount of care to vulnerable populations, Medicaid patients, and the uninsured (HHS, AHRQ, 2020). During the COVID-19 pandemic, there was even greater need for this support to vulnerable populations (Pugh, 2020; Morse, 2020). Often, these hospitals are teaching hospitals and AHCs. This does not mean these hospitals do not or could not serve patients with sufficient reimbursement; however, it is typically the case that many of their patients cannot meet reimbursement requirements for services. In some cases, potential patients with insurance do not want to go to these hospitals, reducing access to effective reimbursement funds. Patients with limited or no reimbursement also tend to have more complex care needs due to several factors, such as low income, medical vulnerability, complex social needs, limited preventive care, and many experience other SDOH, as discussed in other chapters. Some of these patients have chronic medical conditions that have not been adequately treated. Other complications include socioeconomic problems, language issues impacting health literacy, and immigrant status that may impact access to services and finances, all of which contribute to the need for complex healthcare treatment and support. The safety net hospital system struggles to operate effectively to meet the complex medical and social services for vulnerable populations, but they need sufficient reimbursement for services to cover their operating costs. These systems require changes to meet the needs of often complex patients, provide quality care, and remain financially stable (Dickson et al., 2022)
It is important for nurses to understand basic information about reimbursement. Patients today frequently worry about payment for care. Questions that arise are: Do patients have insurance coverage? How much of their care will be covered by insurance and how much of it will be out-of-pocket that they must pay? Will they get the treatment they need from the providers they prefer? Experiencing an illness is difficult for any patient and the patient's family, and to add worry about payment for services increases stress and can have an impact on a patient's health as well as the patient's response to the health problem and outcomes. This stress can affect whether patients can follow treatment recommendations. Can the patient afford needed medications, or do the costs compromise the patient's ability to buy food or pay rent? Can the patient afford to take a bus or taxi to a doctor's appointment? Can the patient afford to take time off from work for an appointment? None of this is simple, and these factors have a major impact on health outcomes.
The Third-Party Payer System
The U.S. healthcare delivery system is mostly funded through a third-party payer system (insurance) that is primarily employer based, with healthcare services paid by someone other (insurer) than the patient and services provided mostly in private sector HCOs, but also in some public or government HCOs. This means if your employer does not offer an insurance benefit, you must purchase your own insurance, apply for Medicaid or Medicare if you are eligible, or go without insurance. Under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), this has become more complicated, and it is a law that continues to experience conflict about its provisions and changes. Examples of private third-party payers are UnitedHealth Group, Humana, and others. Medicare and Medicaid are government programs but also third-party payers, but they are not employers. With third-party payers, the patient pays for part of the care, but the payment for most patient care goes through another party, the insurer (the third-party payer). Typically, the patient or enrollee in the insurance policy is covered as part of a group, most likely through the enrollee's employer healthcare policies and offered as an employee benefit. Some employers allow employees to choose from several policy plan options of varying cost with identified covered services.
Fee-for-service is the most common reimbursement model in the United States. In this model, physicians or other providers, such as hospitals, bill separately for each patient encounter or service that they provide rather than receiving a salary or a set payment per patient enrolled. The third-party payer pays the bills, but the enrollee usually has some payment responsibilities that vary from one policy to another. This is a complex area, and nurses, as consumers of health care and as healthcare providers, need to understand the basics. Enrollees (patients) may pay any or all of the following:
Both the deductible and the copayment represent the patient's annual out-of-pocket expenses, in addition to the annual fee or premium that the employee pays for the coverage. These expenses have been steadily increasing for consumers, some years more than others, and these costs are expected to increase. Employers also pay a portion of the annual insurance fee. Fees vary from policy to policy and from one employer to another. There is no requirement in the United States that every employer provide healthcare insurance coverage-there is also no universal healthcare coverage in the United States. The ACA did increase the number of employers who offer insurance to employees and assist in covering more people; however, some of this may change in the future if the law is repealed, new legislation is passed, or changes are made to the ACA.
Annual limits are also important as they define the maximum amount that enrollees must pay per year if health services are required; after that level is reached, they no longer must contribute to the payment for that year. For example, suppose the employee or enrollee has bills exceeding $5,000, and the annual limit is $5,000. After paying $5,000, this enrollee or patient would not have to pay any more for care that year; the patient is 100% covered for care for the remainder of that year.
Some employees may include their families in their employer insurance coverage if this is part of the employer benefit. The ACA now requires insurers to allow families to include uninsured adult children up to age 26 on their insurance, even if the adult child is no longer dependent on the parents. Typically, employees pay more per year for family insurance, and there may be different requirements for the family (for example, a higher annual out-of-pocket limit) than for individual employee coverage.
Another critical reimbursement element is preexisting conditions. A preexisting condition is a medical condition that a person developed before the person applied for a particular health insurance policy. In the past this type of condition could affect the person's (enrollee or employee) ability to get coverage or how much the enrollee must pay for it. What is considered a preexisting condition? Differences in how policies answer this question have long been a problem; however, this has changed, and legally, insurers cannot apply a preexisting condition requirement to insurers as a reason to deny insurance coverage or charge more for coverage.
Government Reimbursement of Healthcare Services
State and federal governments cover a large portion of the healthcare costs in the United States for government employees. This does not represent universal health coverage; it just covers government employees. The United States is one of the few industrialized countries that does not have universal coverage.
There are several types of government-sponsored reimbursement, which do not require government employment but do apply to certain populations. The largest programs are Medicare and Medicaid, which are managed by the CMS as part of the HHS. In 1965, Title XVIII, an amendment to the Social Security Act, established Medicare. Medicare is the federal health insurance program for people aged 65 and older, persons with disabilities, and people with end-stage renal disease. As of March 2023, Medicare had 65,748,297 beneficiaries, and this number increases each year (HHS, CMS, 2023a). The need for Medicare coverage is growing because of the increase in the population older than age 65. There are several parts to Medicare: Part A covers hospital services; Part B covers physician and outpatient care; Part C, referred to as Medicare Advantage, offers Medicare-approved private insurance plans that cover Part A and B services, but Medicare enrollees may choose one of these plans-the plans may charge different fees; and Part D provides coverage for prescriptions. Medicare beneficiaries must pay a portion of costs for Part B and prescriptions (Part D). Medicare does not pay for long-term care but does cover some skilled nursing and home health care for specific conditions.
The CMS sets standards and monitors Medicare services and payment. Medicare covers many patients in acute care today. It is a very important part of the U.S. healthcare delivery system that supports older citizens and other specified populations; however, there is concern about financing this program in the future because of the increase in the number of citizens who will be 65 and older, and this will increase costs. The CMS is also concerned about quality care, as discussed in other chapters in this text.
Medicaid, established in 1965 by Title XIX of the Social Security Act, is the federal/state program for certain categories of low-income people. Medicaid and the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) cover health- and long-term care services for more than 93,815,749 Americans, including the aged, the blind, disabled persons, and people who are eligible to receive federally assisted income maintenance payments (HHS, CMS, 2023b). The number of people enrolled in Medicaid is increasing, and this has been influenced by the ACA, as more people are now eligible for Medicaid due to changes in the program made by the ACA to increase insurance coverage for many. The Medicaid program is funded by both federal funds and state funds, but each state sets its own guidelines and administers the state's Medicaid program. The federal poverty guidelines establish the annual income level for poverty as defined by the federal government and are important in identifying people who meet coverage criteria for Medicaid reimbursement.
Covered Medicaid services include inpatient care (excluding psychiatric or behavioral health); outpatient care with certain stipulations; laboratory and radiology services; care provided by certified pediatric and family nurse practitioners when licensed to practice under state law; nursing facility services (long-term care) for beneficiaries aged 21 and older; early and periodic screening, diagnosis, and treatment for children younger than age 21; family planning services and supplies; physician services; medical and surgical care; dental services; home health care for beneficiaries who are entitled to nursing facility services under the state's Medicaid plan; certified nurse-midwifery services; pregnancy-related services and services for other conditions that might complicate pregnancy; and 60 days' postpartum pregnancy-related services.
A second group of persons eligible for Medicaid is the medically needy. These are persons who have too much money (which may be in savings) to be eligible categorically for Medicaid but who require extensive care that would consume all their resources. Each state must include the following populations in this group: pregnant women through a 60-day postpartum period; children younger than the age of 18; certain newborns for one year; and certain protected blind persons. States may add others to this list. The federal government requires that each state cover, at a minimum, persons who qualify for Aid to Families with Dependent Children, all needy children younger than age 21, persons who qualify for old-age assistance, persons who qualify for Aid to the Blind, persons who are permanently or totally disabled, and those older than 65 who are on welfare.
Federal and state governments also reimburse care through the following organizations and methods:
The Uninsured and the Underinsured
A large part of the population in the United States is uninsured or underinsured (that is, they do not have enough insurance coverage to pay for their needs). The National Health Interview Survey reported the following based on data from 2019 interviews (HHS, CDC, 2023).
The uninsured and underinsured need healthcare services-preventive, ongoing, acute, and chronic care. They also have complex social and economic needs related to employment, housing, finances, food, transportation, and education. Discharge planning to meet these needs should include a thorough assessment of the patient's needs at home and a plan to ensure that patients receive the care they need posthospitalization, including an assessment of SDOH. Complex and vulnerable populations are at serious risk for limited care access.
Stop and Consider 4 |
---|
The United States does not have a universal healthcare reimbursement system. |
The Nursing Organization Within the Hospital
RNs are members of the nation's largest healthcare profession, and they practice wherever people need nursing care. There has been a serious shortage of all types of nurses in the United States in recent years. Although this trend slowed down somewhat, it is expected to increase again as more nurses retire and the population ages requiring more care. The COVID-19 pandemic has had an impact on nursing school enrollment and also some students may have had problems completing nursing requirements in the typical time frame and then obtaining licensure due to nursing education programs experiencing problems with getting clinical sites and faculty during the pandemic, use of e-learning, and also the economic situation impacting student ability to pay for education and, in some cases, led to a reduction in government funding. The shortage of nursing faculty continues to be a major, long-term problem, as discussed in the content on nursing education in this text, and this affects the number of students nursing programs may admit.
Nurses assume critical roles in a variety of healthcare settings-a topic explored throughout this text. The focus of this chapter is on hospitals as one example of an HCO. Nursing services may be organized differently in hospitals. The traditional nursing organization-which is still the most common type-is the nursing department. In this model, RNs, LPNs/LVNs, and patient care/nursing assistants are the staff in the nursing department, which also includes unit support staff or unit clerks (secretary and other titles) and other support administrative staff. The title for the unit clerk position varies, but this is the person who helps with clinical unit administrative issues, such as records, supplies, reception at the central desk area, and so on.
The second and newer organization model is a patient services department. In this case, the department focuses on the function of multiple patient services, not just nursing. Other patient care services might include medical records, respiratory therapy, infusion therapy, infection control, physical therapy, and so on. The configuration varies widely from one hospital to another. Figures 8-5 and 8-6 provide examples of this type of organization. Figure 8-7 describes a hospital unit structure.
Figure 8-5 An example: Nursing department organizational chart.
An organizational chart depicts the hierarchy of a nursing department.
At the top is the Chief Nursing Officer. Below, there are directors for nursing research, evidence-based practice, and staff development. Below them are directors for specific nursing areas: Director of Medical Nursing, overseeing Medical Units A, B, and C. Director of Surgical Nursing, overseeing Surgical Units A, B, OR, and Post-Anesthesia Recovery. Director of Intensive Care Nursing, overseeing I C U, C C U, and Step-Down Units. Director of Ambulatory Care, overseeing Clinics, E D, and Urgent Care, and Director of Women's Health overseeing Gynecology Unit, Labor and Delivery, Postpartum, and N I C U.
Figure 8-6 An example: Patient services organizational chart.
An organizational chart of the patient services department.
At the top is the V P Patient services. Directly reporting to the V P Patient Services is the Director of Nursing, who oversees Nursing Services, Nursing Research, E B P, and Staff Development and Education. Parallel to this structure, other directors report to the V P Patient Services: Director of Pharmacy, Director of Dietary Services, Director of Medical Records, and Director of Quality Improvement.
Figure 8-7 An example: Medical nursing unit organizational chart.
An organizational chart depicts the hierarchy of a medical nursing unit.
The Chief Nursing Officer is at the top, followed by the Director of Medical Nursing. Under the Director is the Nurse Manager for Unit A, who oversees Area Coordinators and three R N Team Leaders, Team A, Team B, and Team C. Each R N Team L P Ns or L V Ns, and Nursing Assistants.
An RN is the designated leader as noted in Figures 8-5 through 8-7, which illustrate department models. An RN must be the overall leader of nursing services to meet The Joint Commission accreditation standards. The nurse leader title has changed over time, as noted earlier. Given that nurses account for the largest percentage of hospital staff and provide most of the direct care, it is critical that a nurse leader represents the nurses in the organization. The nurse leader needs to be recognized in the HCO as an important leader and participate in major HCO decision-making.
In the 1970s and 1980s, directors of nursing began to gain more power, and their titles often changed to vice president for nursing or patient services in recognition of their organizational leadership role-but the focus was still on nursing. During this time, increasing numbers of nursing leaders began to complete graduate degrees. It was recognized that they were running large, complex departments that represented a significant portion of the overall hospital budget. Gradually, the vice president of nursing (VPN) was included in the hospital's budget process as an equal partner. The next change was the evolution of the vice president of patient services position, in which the nurse leader is responsible for more than just the nursing services. This was a major shift, but the idea that a nurse could manage other healthcare disciplines changed very slowly. As is true for all such information about hospitals, there is great variation from one hospital to another. The size of the hospital has an impact on how the nursing services are organized.
More nurses today are also assuming positions in hospital administration that are not related to just nursing; for example, a nurse could be the chief operating officer or CEO. This is a major shift, but there are not many nurses in these positions. Nurses are also serving on boards of directors for a variety of HCOs in acute care and in public/community organizations. Today, nurses who serve in nursing leadership positions in an HCO need to be competent in administrative and management responsibilities, such as planning, budgeting, staffing, QI, effective decision-making, communicating, coordinating, and public speaking, and must demonstrate leadership. The nurse administrator must involve staff in decision-making, support teamwork, and work with other healthcare professionals to support effective interprofessional teamwork to ensure quality care, EBP, and a healthy work environment. The nursing organization or department includes a variety of nursing management staff. Typically, there are three levels of management:
Participation in nursing committees and interprofessional committees provides opportunities for nurses to be directly involved in decision-making and have an impact on care delivery. Some of the committees typically found in hospitals focus on policies and procedures, QI, staffing, staff development/education, medical records and documentation, pharmacy, EBP, and research. Some committees are special task forces that address specific issues for a short period of time-for example, preparing for change to a new computerized documentation system.
Stop and Consider 5 |
---|
The organization of nursing services has an impact on its staff. |
Organizational Culture
Typically, culture refers to an individual person's culture, the culture of a group in a country, or a country's culture, but there is also organizational culture. The interest in organizational culture is not new but has become more important. Curtin described organizational culture in the following way, and it still applies today:
There is in each institution an implicit, invisible, intrinsic, informal, and yet instantly recognizable weltanschauung that is best described as corporate culture. Like most important things, it is difficult to define or even describe. It is not corporate climate, organizational climate, or corporate identity. The corporate culture embodies the organizational values that implicitly and explicitly specify norms, shape attitudes, and guide the behaviors of the members of the organization. (2001, p. 219)
Organizational culture has an impact on nursing staff and their practice. The HCO, as a whole, has a culture. Nursing within an HCO also has a culture; the nursing department and even separate divisions or units may have differences in their cultures. Potential new staff members need information about the culture of the organizations that they are considering for employment. Students should also identify organizational cultural issues in the units where they have clinical experiences so that they can better understand what this type of culture represents and its impact on the work environment and on patient care.
Two terms are often used to describe organizational culture: dissonant and consonant. Hospital leaders need to be aware of the label that applies to their organization's culture. A dissonant culture means that the organization is not functioning effectively whereas a consonant culture is effective. Dissonant organizations have the following characteristics that still apply today to these organizations (Jones & Redman, 2000, p. 605):
Today, there is growing concern about staff incivility and bullying-nurse to nurse and nurse to other healthcare staff. This is a symptom of a dissonant culture. Additional information on incivility is discussed in other chapters in this text. Incivility has an impact on performance, quality improvement, and teamwork, as well as staff recruitment and retention. Healthcare organizations are recognizing the dangers of this type of behavior and working to reduce the stress that leads to this behavior. The goal is to develop and maintain a consonant culture, or a functional and effective organization. People do not like to go to work in stressful environments and want to work in organizations that are effective, creative, and productive. How does an organization attain these characteristics? The hospital's formal framework lays the groundwork for an effective, healthy workplace. This includes the hospital's structure and functions, chain of command, rules and regulations, and policies and procedures. The hospital's vision and mission statements are important. The vision statement describes the hospital's values and its view of the future and provides direction for the organization-what it aspires to be. The mission statement describes the hospital's purpose and its current state. Hospitals also identify goals and objectives that flow from their vision and mission statements and should guide the HCO activities. These statements are part of the HCO's process and are very important to its culture. The vision, mission, goals, and objectives should not be documents that are filed away, but rather their messages should be implemented in the hospital's processes, structure, and staff behavior and attitudes.
It is not always easy to describe an organization's culture. The first response to an organization's culture takes the form of a gut feeling that a patient has when the patient enters the hospital and observes its physical appearance, how staff respond, the ease of finding one's way around, services set up for the consumer, and so on. The following are other considerations that have an impact on an HCO's culture:
Nurses usually know which hospitals are functional (consonant) organizations in the communities in which they live and practice. They share this information with colleagues, and this can have an impact on the recruitment of new staff.
Workforce diversity and patient diversity both influence the hospital's culture. All the people who work in the organization and all the people who interact with the organization, such as the patients and their families, public/community healthcare organizations, and community members and representatives, affect the organization's culture. Workforce diversity has become a critical issue in health care-specifically, there is a need for greater diversity in all healthcare professions. Labor laws affect this diversity. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Executive Order 11246 prohibit employer discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 prohibits discrimination because of disability, including mental illness, if the person can complete the job requirements. These federal laws apply to any hospital (or any type of HCO) that receives federal funds, such as Medicare or Medicaid reimbursement. On a practical level, this means nearly all hospitals are subject to these requirements because few do not provide services to patients covered by these two payment systems or receive other types of federal funding/payment. Language is another issue that is related to diversity. Hospitals need to have access to interpreters to effectively communicate with patients if staff cannot do so.
Another critical aspect of the hospital's culture is its effectiveness. Since 2001, there has been more interest in whether an HCO environment is a healing environment. This is just as difficult to define or describe as an organization's culture. Some of the factors considered when assessing the environment are (1) privacy, (2) air quality, (3) noise levels, (4) views from windows, and (5) visual characteristics. Patient needs can vary and, in turn, affect the type of healing environment needed. The older adult may require more safety measures to prevent falls, but if restraining patients is used to accomplish this, the person (patient, family) may then have a negative view of the environment and healthcare delivery. Restraining a patient may prevent injury, but the patient may also feel imprisoned and punished or abused. Its use should be based on assessment and identification of the best intervention-but at no time should restraining be a long-term intervention without routine assessment as to the patient's status and continuing need. Older adults may have problems hearing and can tolerate more noise. Others may not be able to tolerate a lot of noise and may complain that they cannot sleep in the hospital. From a historical perspective, Florence Nightingale's view of care was associated with healing and considering the patient's need for fresh air, cleanliness, quiet, diet, and light. Other aspects of a healing environment include the physical environment-use of color, sameness or variety, sense of warmth in furnishings, type of artwork on the walls, and so on. Some colors are more peaceful than others. Put simply, are the architecture and furnishings patient/person-centered and safe? More attention needs to be paid to the physical environment and consideration of changes that improve the environment-leading to a healing environment.
Planetree is a nonprofit organization concerned with the environmental impact of the delivery system on health care. It is one example of a model of healing in healthcare environments. The focus is on body, mind, and spirit, with active patient and family involvement. Hospitals that meet specific criteria can be designated as Planetree hospitals. This model of patient/person-centered care, emphasizes a systemized approach to delivering healthcare in a way that centers on the perspective of the whole patient and their loved ones, while promoting a healthy, encouraging environment for caregivers and addressing the health needs of the organization's surrounding community (Planetree, 2021). Many hospitals are now certified as Planetree hospitals when they meet criteria that emphasize a healing person-centered environment as proposed by Planetree.
Stop and Consider 6 |
---|
An organization's culture has an impact on every nurse in the HCO, and nurses have an impact on the organization's culture. |
Changes in Healthcare Delivery
Historically, hospitals have experienced many changes. In the past, hospitals had a significant role in nursing education, but their most important role-then and now-is the provision of healthcare services in their communities. What has been the history of hospitals? The reengineering of health care-that is, the redesigning of how care is provided and how the organization functions-has led to major changes in HCOs. Many HCOs have undergone some level of reengineering in the last decade. This might include restructuring, developing new services, improving processes and systems, or perhaps decreasing services. A common response to periods of healthcare worker shortages has been to redesign how work is done and by whom. If there are not enough providers, the organization needs to consider how staff and management are working and how work processes and resources can be improved to be more effective. As hospitals change, many factors influence the need for change and how it occurs. Some of these factors were highlighted earlier in Figure 8-1.
Change is inevitable in any type of organization today, but particularly in health care. Science and knowledge have driven some of this change, such as the development of technology that has affected diagnosis and treatment options and increased digital options, but there are other factors to consider. Change is a process that is driven by forces that motivate a person or an organization to consider what needs altering. The key is to be clear about this need and understand the why before taking the next steps. It is also important to consider whether the staff is ready for the change. Staff can act as either barriers to or facilitators of change. Staff members are typically tired of changes and feel that there are too many. They often also feel left out of the decision process that leads to changes. In this case, they may be critical of the change or feel no commitment to the success of change. This attitude, in turn, becomes a major barrier to successful change. For example, if staff do not understand the need behind a decision to change a form in the medical record, it will be more difficult to train them in the use of the new form, and it may be difficult to get them to even use the form or to use it correctly. The complexity of the change and how frequently changes are made can lead to overload for staff. The goal is to have staff supporting the change so that they will be facilitators of change. Understanding resistance to change can help in preparing for change and in developing any training that might be required. When changes are planned within a hospital, planners need to consider the impact that the changes may have on policies and procedures; accreditation and regulation requirements; financial issues; the structure of the organization; the ways in which staff do their work; patients, visitors, and students (for example, nursing, medical, other); and much more. Other chapters in this text discuss change and its implications, such as QI, which often identifies change needs.
This chapter focused on healthcare organizations, with acute care hospitals as the major example of an HCO. Understanding how hospitals are structured and their processes (functions) helps the nurse practice in this setting. The departments and team members assume important roles in how the organization functions. The U.S. healthcare system has been undergoing many changes due to policy changes, legislation, changes in population demographics and health problems, new technology and treatments, and so on. Nurses are involved in these changes and should participate in the change process.
Throughout this chapter and others such as on public/community health, the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has been mentioned. It is a defining moment in history and in healthcare delivery and led to many changes and major healthcare, social, and economic problems that required complex and quick decisions. In many situations, we have been unprepared. It is hoped that we can learn and make changes as needed to be better prepared for this type of major crisis in the future, but we can also learn from the experience to improve current healthcare delivery. The COVID-19 pandemic required difficult decisions, such as the implementation of the crisis standards of care (CSC). These standards address healthcare system crisis when the degree of resource shortage requires decisions that place a patient or provider at risk of a poor outcome. These situations arose in most jurisdictions and required a systematic, coordinated response (Hick et al., 2021; NAM, 2020). A critical element in healthcare delivery that must be assessed is equity. During public health emergencies, such as what happened with the COVID-19 pandemic, the acute care healthcare system experienced problems with surge capacity and impacted who received care and when, or health equity. The system had problems providing efficient and effective responses with its usual strategies. For example, they encountered limits in sufficient and qualified staff; the need for more space and beds; medical supplies and equipment, for example, accessibility to protective equipment for staff (PPE); and the need for blood, oxygen, and medications. At the same time, the health systems and communities experienced higher levels of morbidity with risk of complications and mortality. Some of these communities chose to apply crisis standards of care to give them more flexibility to resolve the problems (Hick et al., 2021; NAM, 2020). Application of these standards requires that the healthcare system and the healthcare providers use timely data collection and analysis in the community. They must collaborate, coordinate, and use effective, routine sharing of information among local, state, and national agencies, healthcare providers and organizations, government at all levels, and any other relevant stakeholders. A major limitation with these standards is it may mean that care will be limited for some at the time they need it or later if resources are no longer available, for example, routine care needs and long-term needs. This is difficult for healthcare providers, patients, and families as there may be treatment delays for routine health problems due to the use of CSC. It is not easy to decide to apply these standards, and the decision needs to be made carefully even during a time when there may be urgency. The ANA commented about this type of decision and community implications for individuals, families, vulnerable populations, and the community by noting the need to promote equality of person and equity in distribution of risks and benefits in society. There is a tension between the patient-centered approach to providing the maximum individual care for each patient and the public-focused approach to fair resource allocation during crisis conditions. A public health approach to ethics can provide guidance in balancing the tension between the needs of the individual and those of the group (ANA, 2021). This relates to the ANA Code of Ethics (2015). It is important to recognize that public health emergencies require clinicians to change their practice, including in some situations, acting to prioritize the community above the individual in fairly allocating scarce resources (Berlinger et al., 2020). Application of the crisis standards in acute and public/community health also impacts healthcare professionals' personal ethics when they must make difficult decisions about patients, patient care, and the community that may limit care and resources for some and feel stress personally about this type of decision. This is not something that nurses want to consider but may need to do.
Stop and Consider 7 |
---|
Healthcare delivery is not static; there are frequent factors that change and then impact health care. |
Discussion
Data from Bilyeu, T., et al. (2023). LPNs in modified care delivery models. American Nurse, 18(9). https://www.myamericannurse.com/lpns-in-modified-care-delivery-models/?partnerref=Nurseline+20230919&utm_source=sfmc&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Nurseline+20230919&utm_term=LPNs+in+modified+care+delivery+models&utm_id=100375&sfmc_id=11576504
Link:https://www.medicare.gov/hospitalcompare/search.html
Connect to Information for EBP
Li, Z., & Gephart, S. (2023). Prevalence and characteristics of hospital nurse leaders' turnover intention. JONA, 53(9), 445-452.
Questions:
Write a description of a hospital where you have had clinical experience. Consider the information in this chapter as you describe the organization. Reflect on its culture and how you felt when you were in the organization over the period you were assigned to this clinical site. How do you think staff, patients, and families might feel? Based on your experiences, what could be improved in the organization? When you first entered the hospital and one of its units, what did you feel like? Consider all your senses in your response.
In your teams, search the internet for a hospital website in your state. Each team member should select a different hospital, preferably including urban and rural hospitals of different types and sizes. See if you can find information on that hospital's vision, mission, goals, and objectives. Many hospital websites include this information. After you find an example, review the information. How does this information apply to nursing? Then, compare the information collected by each team member and discuss it.
Case 1
It is time to interview for your first hospital job. You are not sure what you should do in the interview and what questions you should ask. You are having lunch with fellow students, and all of you are focused on this issue.
Case 1 Questions
Case 2
You are a staff nurse on a surgical unit. The nurse manager has formed a task force to provide input on the unit's budget. She asks you to serve on the task force. You tell her you do not feel competent because you have been a nurse for only one year, but she says she wants fresh input. Now, you find yourself at the first meeting. The chair opens the meeting with some questions. How would you respond to them?