Organophosphorus (OP) compounds and carbamates, also known as cholinesterase inhibitors, are widely used pesticides. These agents, which comprise thousands of structurally related substances, are responsible for a large number of suicidal or accidental poisonings, with the greatest mortality (an estimated 150,000 deaths per year) in rural areas of developing countries.
During the 1930s, German military scientists synthesized numerous OP compounds, including parathion and several highly potent chemical warfare agents (eg, GA [tabun], GB [sarin], and GD [soman]; see warfare agents and Table II-62). Because these chemical weapons affect the autonomic nervous system, they are sometimes referred to as nerve agents. Chemical attacks on civilians in Japan (1994 and 1995) and Syria (2013 and 2017) affected thousands of urban civilians who were exposed to the OP compound sarin. Accidental poisoning with cholinesterase inhibitors can also occur from the contamination of food or beverages.
Carbamates, although less deadly than OP agents, are used frequently as pesticides, fungicides, herbicides, rodenticides, and medications (eg, pyridostigmine) to treat neurologic disorders such as myasthenia gravis.
There is a wide spectrum of relative potency of the OP and carbamate compounds (Tables II-46, II-47, and II-48).
Agent | CAS Number | Chemical Structurea | WHO Classificationb | GHS Classificationc |
---|---|---|---|---|
Acephate | 30560-19-1 | OP (diM) | II | 4 |
Alanycarb | 83130-01-2 | C | II | 4 |
Aldicarb | 116-06-3 | C | Ia | 1 |
Anilofos | 64249-01-0 | OP (diM) | II | 4 |
Azamethiphos | 35575-96-3 | OP (diM) | II | 4 |
Azinphos-methyl | 86-50-0 | OP (dM) | Ib | 2 |
Azinphos-ethyl | 2642-71-9 | OP (diE) | Ib | 2 |
Bendiocarb | 22781-23-3 | C | II | 3 |
Benfuracarb | 82560-54-1 | C | II | 3 |
Bensulide | 741-58-2 | OP | II | 3 |
Butamifos | 36335-67-8 | OP | II | 4 |
Butocarboxim | 34681-10-2 | C | Ib | 3 |
Butoxycarboxim | 34681-23-7 | C | Ib | 3 |
Cadusafos | 95465-99-9 | OP | Ib | 2 |
Carbetamide | 16118-49-3 | C | U | 5 |
Carbaryl | 63-25-2 | C | II | 3 |
Carbofuran | 1563-66-2 | C | Ib | 1 |
Carbosulfan | 55285-14-8 | C | II | 3 |
Chlorethoxyfos | 54593-83-8 | OP (diE) | Ia | 1 |
Chlorfenvinphos | 470-90-6 | OP (diE) | Ib | 2 |
Chlormephos | 24934-91-6 | OP (diE) | Ia | 2 |
Chlorpropham | 101-21-3 | C | U | 5 |
Chlorpyrifos | 2921-88-2 | OP (diE) | II | 3 |
Chlorpyrifos-methyl | 5598-13-0 | OP (diM) | III | 5 |
Coumaphos | 56-72-4 | OP (diE) | Ib | 2 |
Cyanophos | 2636-26-2 | OP (diM) | II | 4 |
Demeton-S-methyl | 919-86-8 | OP (diM) | Ib | 2 |
Diazinon | 333-41-5 | OP (diE) | II | 4 |
Dichlorvos (DDVP) | 62-73-7 | OP (diM) | Ib | 3 |
Dicrotophos | 141-66-2 | OP (diM) | Ib | 2 |
Dimethoate | 60-51-5 | OP (dM) | II | 3 |
Disulfoton | 298-04-4 | OP (diE) | Ia | 1 |
Edifenphos | 17109-49-8 | OP | Ib | 3 |
EPN | 2104-64-5 | OP | Ia | 2 |
Ethiofencarb | 29973-13-5 | C | Ib | 3 |
Ethion | 563-12-2 | OP (diE) | II | 3 |
Ethoprophos | 13194-48-4 | OP | Ia | 2 |
Famphur | 52-85-7 | OP (diM) | Ib | 2 |
Fenamiphos | 22224-92-6 | OP | Ib | 2 |
Fenitrothion | 122-14-5 | OP (diM) | II | 4 |
Fenobucarb | 3766-81-2 | C | II | 4 |
Fenoxycarb | 79127-80-3 | C | U | 5 |
Fenthiocarb | 62850-32-2 | C | II | 4 |
Fenthion | 55-38-9 | OP (diM) | II | 3 |
Formetanate | 22259-30-9 | C | Ib | 2 |
Fosamine | 25954-13-6 | OP | III | 5 |
Furathiocarb | 65907-30-4 | C | Ib | 2 |
Heptenophos | 23560-59-0 | OP (diM) | Ib | 3 |
Isoprocarb | 2631-40-5 | C | II | 4 |
Isoxathion | 18854-04-8 | OP (diE) | Ib | 3 |
Malathion | 121-75-5 | OP (diM) | III | 5 |
Mecarbam | 2595-54-2 | C | Ib | 2 |
Methacrifos | 62610-77-9 | OP (diM) | II | 4 |
Methamidophos | 10265-92-6 | OP (diM) | Ib | 2 |
Methidathion | 950-37-8 | OP (diM) | Ib | 2 |
Methiocarb | 2032-65-7 | C | Ib | 2 |
Methomyl | 16752-77-5 | C | Ib | 2 |
Metolcarb | 1129-41-5 | C | II | 3 |
Mevinphos | 26718-65-0 | OP (diM) | Ia | 1 |
Monocrotophos | 6923-22-4 | OP (diM) | Ib | 2 |
MPMC (xylylcarb) | 2425-10-7 | C | II | 4 |
Naled | 300-76-5 | OP (diM) | II | 4 |
Omethoate | 1113-02-6 | OP (diM) | Ib | 2 |
Oxamyl | 23135-22-0 | C | Ib | 2 |
Oxydemeton-methyl | 301-12-2 | OP (diM) | Ib | 3 |
Parathion | 56-38-2 | OP (diE) | Ia | 1 |
Parathion-methyl | 298-00-0 | OP (diM) | Ia | 1 |
Phenthoate | 2597-03-7 | OP (diM) | II | 4 |
Phorate | 298-02-2 | OP (diE) | Ia | 1 |
Phosalone | 2310-17-0 | OP (diE) | II | 3 |
Phosmet | 732-11-6 | OP (diM) | II | 3 |
Phosphamidon | 13171-21-6 | OP (diM) | Ia | 2 |
Phoxim | 14816-18-3 | OP (diE) | II | 4 |
Piperophos | 24151-93-7 | OP | II | 4 |
Pirimicarb | 23103-98-2 | C | II | 3 |
Primiphos-methyl | 29232-93-7 | OP | II | 4 |
Profenofos | 41198-08-7 | OP | II | 4 |
Propetamphos | 31218-83-4 | OP | Ib | 3 |
Propoxur | 114-26-1 | C | II | 3 |
Prothiofos | 34643-46-4 | OP | II | 4 |
Pyraclofos | 77458-01-6 | OP | II | 3 |
Pyrazophos | 13457-18-6 | OP (diE) | II | 4 |
Pyridaphenthion | 119-12-0 | OP (diE) | II | 4 |
Quinalphos | 13593-03-8 | OP (diE) | II | 3 |
Sulfotep | 3689-24-5 | OP (diE) | Ia | 1 |
Tebuprimifos | 96182-53-5 | OP (diE) | Ia | 1 |
Temephos | 3383-96-8 | OP (diM) | III | 5 |
Terbufos | 13071-79-9 | OP (diE) | Ia | 1 |
Tetrachlorvinphos | 22248-79-9 | OP (diM) | III | 5 |
Thiodicarb | 59669-26-0 | C | II | 3 |
Thiofanox | 39196-18-4 | C | Ib | 2 |
Thiometon | 640-5-3 | OP (diM) | Ib | 3 |
Triazophos | 24017-47-8 | OP (diM) | Ib | 3 |
Trichlorfon | 52-68-6 | OP (diM) | II | 3 |
Vamidothion | 2275-23-2 | OP (diM) | Ib | 3 |
XMC (cosban) | 2655-14-3 | C | II | 4 |
aC, carbamate; OP (diM), dimethyl organophosphate; OP (diE), diethyl organophosphate. Note: Some organophosphates have a chemical structure other than dimethoxy or diethoxy. For example, ethoprophos is a dipropyl compound.
bWorld Health Organization (WHO) Pesticide Classification Scheme (based on oral LD50 values in the rat): Class I, extremely or highly hazardous; Class II, moderately hazardous; Class III, slightly hazardous (see Table II-47).
cGlobally Harmonized System (GHS) for classification and labeling: range of toxicity 1-5, with 1 indicating the most hazardous and 5 indicating the least hazardous based on the best available toxicity (eg, LD50) data (see Table II-48).
Note: The likelihood of serious toxicity depends not only on the dose and type of pesticide but also on the route of exposure, circumstances of the exposure, type of co-ingested solvents, and pre-existing cholinesterase activity. In addition, agents that are highly lipid soluble, such as fenthion and sulfoton, may cause prolonged intoxication.
WHO Class | LD50 for the Rat (mg/kg of body weight) | ||
---|---|---|---|
Oral | Dermal | ||
Ia | Extremely hazardous | <5 | <50 |
Ib | Highly hazardous | 5-50 | 50-200 |
II | Moderately hazardous | 50-2,000 | 200-2,000 |
III | Slightly hazardous | >2,000 | >2,000 |
U | Unlikely to present acute hazard | ≥5,000 | ≥5,000 |
aReproduced, with permission, from World Health Organization: The WHO Recommended Classification of Pesticides by Hazard and Guidelines to Classification: 2009, Breathing. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2010.
GHS Category | Oral Classification Criteria | Dermal Classification Criteria | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
LD50 (mg/kg)a | Hazard Statement | LD50 (mg/kg)b | Hazard Statement | |
1 | <5 | Fatal if swallowed | <50 | Fatal in contact with skin |
2 | 5-50 | Fatal if swallowed | 50-200 | Fatal in contact with skin |
3 | 50-300 | Toxic if swallowed | 200-1,000 | Toxic in contact with skin |
4 | 300-2,000 | Harmful if swallowed | 1,000-2,000 | Harmful in contact with skin |
5 | 2,000-5,000 | May be harmful if swallowed | 2,000-5,000 | May be harmful in contact with skin |
aFor oral data, the rat is the preferred species, although data from other species may be appropriate when their use is scientifically justified.
bFor dermal data, the rat or the rabbit is the preferred species, although data from other species may be appropriate when their use is scientifically justified.
cReproduced, with permission, from World Health Organization: The WHO Recommended Classification of Pesticides by Hazard and Guidelines to Classification: 2009, QRS interval prolongation. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2010.
Respiratory failure is a major cause of mortality in patients with acute cholinesterase inhibitor toxicity. Acute clinical manifestations may be classified into muscarinic, nicotinic, and CNS effects (see below), all of which can contribute to respiratory failure. In addition, acute lung injury, pulmonary edema, and chemical pneumonitis due to aspiration of hydrocarbon solvents may compound the multiple respiratory derangements that characterize cholinesterase inhibitor poisoning.
Is based on the history of exposure and the presence of characteristic muscarinic, nicotinic, and CNS manifestations of acetylcholine excess. In the majority of cases, the most prominent symptoms are due to excessive muscarinic stimulation. (A useful mnemonic for muscarinic toxicity is DUMBBELSS: diarrhea, urinary incontinence, miosis, bronchospasm, bronchorrhea, emesis, lacrimation, salivation, and sweating.) There may be a noxious solvent odor, and some agents have a strong garlic aroma. A Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score of 13 or lower at presentation is considered a poor prognostic indicator. Other drugs or toxins that increase cholinergic activity, such as nicotine alkaloids, should be considered in the differential diagnosis, and some unrelated classes of pesticides (eg, pyrethroids, amitraz, phosphides) may cause symptoms that resemble OP and carbamate toxicity.